Two completely different physiques...Does every Mr Olympia have to look like Ronnie Coleman? When Ronnie was king, everyone complained that you have to be a mass monster to win...Now that Heath won, everyone says he is too small and narrow, and wants a mass monster back in the seat..I think people root for a competitor till they win...After that the they split hairs, over analyse, and negatively tear apart every weak point there is...
There is truth in what you say that people rage against the champion.
Thing is, Phil isn't the best at what he is - Ronnie was. Nobody disputed that.
Phil IS structurally inferior to many top 10 bodybuilders in the last 20 years.
Not saying he didn't deserve to win, what he's good at - he is genuinely good. But most of us are waiting for better.
It's really quite simple, he has a tiny chest width. It's almost freaky how small it is. It isn't aesthetically pleasing.