So what if someone comes in and wants a great big fat fucking swastika on a cake for a White Supremacy rally?
Should the owner be forced to make the cake???
Retards all of ye, the point is that he won't make the cake BECAUSE THEY ARE GAY, thus discriminating against them, your scenario is not remotely the same. Swastikas are offensive symbolism, it's reasonable to deny making it. They aren't asking for a cake in the shape of a cock going in a mans ass.
Reverse the analogy for the stupid. if the owner denied the cake to a person who may have been a nazi then you have an argument, being gay and having a cake, isn't the same as being a nazi and a nazi shaped cake.
Or take you argument to it;s logical conclusion, someone comes in and wants a cake of infinity, actual infinity. Since they are impossible it's a paradox but he has to make the cake (as you recall, he has to make all cakes.) thus is set on his way into cake making eternity.