I don't agree at all. First of all there are no secrets. Secondly a good coach individualizes the program, that's coaching. If a coach can give an impression of knowing his shit by explaining his methods it should only increase his value in the eyes of this community.
I do remember one thing he said, that you simply can't get as peaked without diuretics as with them. This flies in the face of what many other online coaches today claim, that there simply is no need for diuretics "if you know what you're doing".
Well obviously he's doing something right, as his clients always come in shredded, and he seems to have plenty of them... So why would he want to give away anything when others are paying for it?
Honestly, in this generation, we seem to expect everyone to give us the info because, well, we want it dammit, and there is always someone out there to give it.
In my experience, the ones giving it away for free usually either
A. Dont know shit
Or
B. Can't do it themselves.
As I said in another thread.. just like in the automotive racing industry... the guys on the internet telling others "How it is" are the guys taking 43rd in their amateur local event... the guys like Noel, with winners, are charging and aren't talking unless you pay them.
You always have the exceptions, like Jim (Disgusted), but for the most part, the guys that REALLY know what they're doing are either doing it or getting paid. They're not on getbig giving it to anyone that asks just because we 'think' we know already or we 'think' we deserve it.