I think for most women, personality/charisma and financial stability/good career are by far the two most important things. Looks, physical attractivenesss and overall physical health are probably the next most important thing.
Large, oversized muscles and being ripped are a not a big factor for attracting most women (obviously a small proportion of women are more attracted to muscular physiques than others). If you are lifting weights and "working out" to attract girls, forget it. You would be much better off working on other areas of life and going for a run a few times a week.