I doubt it...when it comes down to it, Phil is more complete, defined and more conditioned.
still... if one dude is taller, wider, and thicker, he usually wins.
If they were the same height and bodyweight as that year's winner, Lee Labrada and Shawn Ray would have plenty of titles right now.
If we reach a point where phil is only a little more detailed and complete - and Ramy just completely outsizes him - taller, wider, and 20 pounds more muscle...
I think they WILL give it to Ramy. Jay was overall likable to the fans. People loved Ronnie. Phil has fans, but seriously, for some reason, most bodybuilding fans think he's a dick for some reason. Maybe he likes it that way, I hear he really tried to act like a dick in that movie they made.
But IMO, it's a little harder to take a title from a cutler or ronnie, as the fans LOVE them. I think Phil might be more likely to lose, all things equal, because he's seen as the bad guy by many fans.