V,
If you didn't expect it to do well, then why did you invest time, effort, and money in it?
It brought in some decent revenue when I first built it. So when a new supplier came along, it was worth giving it another shot as I already owned the domain name and software...the only additional investment I made was running it in a memcache system.
I intend to lower the prices on products slightly to meet the price point and maybe install a coupon system. If it doesn't work, I'll convert the site over to an Amazon affiliate site