here is the problem in a nutshell.. you want to equate physically resisting arrest, which Garner did.. with talking shit. Two totally different things. I can't even begin to tell you how many people I've arrested or observed being arrested that talked shit.. and the arrest was uneventful. I think you are having trouble seeing the difference between talking shit and actively resisting which is what happened in this particular case whether you accept it or not
I guess I think that given ten arrest.... in 2 of them, ,the suspect talking trash would result in the cop using extra force or violating rights in some way.
At least two. You sound like a decent poster and NOT a dick or racist or bully or insecure punk. But some cops really are.
I've been stopped maybe 10 times in my life. I'm always respectful. Only ONCE did the punk ass cop - I remember her name so clearly - she threated a poor college kid with a seatbelt ticket because I tried to explain why I ran the red light. (under construction lane, middle of night, i'd been sitting there for 5+ minutes and no change. She was sitting in dark waiting for me to run it). AND MY SEATBELT WAS ON!
Two months later, she actually won a local award for something - most outstanding amount of tickets, something like that. ANyway, they threatened my poor ass with a false ticket for trying to speak. Fck that. To this day, I hate her guts, and I want ANY cop that lies about ANYTHING to lose that badge.