Author Topic: Bodybuilding judges shouldn't be allowed to prep/coach competitors they judge  (Read 2114 times)

240 is Back

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 102396
  • Complete website for only $300- www.300website.com
imagine NFL owners being able to select and hire their own referees.


but the sport of BBing is so small, the same people that own gyms, run shows, train people - they are bringing all of the $ into the sport and working tons for it... so if their 'athlete' wins the biggest plastic trophy in a local high school gym show on a saturday afternoon, what's the big deal?   

io856

  • Guest
imagine NFL owners being able to select and hire their own referees.


but the sport of BBing is so small, the same people that own gyms, run shows, train people - they are bringing all of the $ into the sport and working tons for it... so if their 'athlete' wins the biggest plastic trophy in a local high school gym show on a saturday afternoon, what's the big deal?  

If you want to train and prep competitors fine, don't judge the competition. Common sense... The competitor is then prepared according to the judge's ideal, emotional connection is generated or any connection that may stem from intensive communication and advice.

The big deal is that the other competitors have spent night and day trying to present the best possible physique. Invested a huge amount of financial, emotional and physical exertion. Put a toll on their health (mental and physical), relationships, work and time resources.

"Plastic trophy" or any other demeaning connotations aside for many if not all competitors, this is their life's work. Some may be at the local level for a variety of reasons, that doesn't discount their passion, dedication and concerned effort. I think competitors deserve impartial judging, at the very least controlling factors which obviously could create impartiality.

Joe Pietaro

  • Getbig III
  • ***
  • Posts: 509
  • Publisher, MuscleSport Magazine
Exactly this.

This combined with the ifbb pledges from the competitors let me know something is amiss. They have all gone for the personal life. Nobody has refuted his allegations about Lindsay shows, Hany Rambod, the judging, etc

My question was that if people participated in Lee's shows like last weekend, would that still count in the NPC towards a national qualification. This makes no sense. Would they pretend it didn't happen. That's not fair to competitors who dieted and paid their money to hold that against them.


Bizarro world-type shit, for sure. Thompson resigns (or was fired, according to the IFBB pros that are doing the barking for the brass), has everything under the sun said about him, retorts with his own scandal-throwing video and then is the main guy at a number of shows representing his former federation.

How the fuck can anyone explain this? Shouldn't a replacement have been found (the Parisos, since they're getting Thompson's old NPC/IFBB TX territory) to promote these shows? Of course, but the 'protectors' are saying that cancelling the shows would have been unfair to the competitors. Replacing the promoter is not cancelling a show.

io856

  • Guest
Bizarro world-type shit, for sure. Thompson resigns (or was fired, according to the IFBB pros that are doing the barking for the brass), has everything under the sun said about him, retorts with his own scandal-throwing video and then is the main guy at a number of shows representing his former federation.

How the fuck can anyone explain this? Shouldn't a replacement have been found (the Parisos, since they're getting Thompson's old NPC/IFBB TX territory) to promote these shows? Of course, but the 'protectors' are saying that cancelling the shows would have been unfair to the competitors. Replacing the promoter is not cancelling a show.
There has to be more to this, no way the NPC/IFBB would associate any further with Thompson after this debacle...
Lee might have sort of pre existing contract
or even a direct association with a venue or something of that nature

Never1AShow

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 7608
  • World Record Holder in French Toast Diving
I heard Navy Mike offered up his handicap parking placard for a higher placing.

powerbar

  • Getbig IV
  • ****
  • Posts: 1407
  • I am a good man.
Promoting doesn't have anything to do with being a judge or chairman for the NPC........or at least it shouldn't.   The man has paid for and planned the event.  Telling him to step down as promoter would require everyone getting their money back and no longer having a contract for the show.  Then someone would have to scramble to get sponsors and a venue.  Its understandable that after this year the NPC won't let him promote a show but canceling a show that people are already training for is much worse for NPC Texas.
Come get me.