I think it is more detrimental as it stagnates the child brain into thinking magical nonsense is real which opens the door for further belief in nonsense and superstition.
Also, why would you not want your child to know that YOU were the one behind the gifts?
To be honest, these are great questions. I've considered this myself.
Ok, so I have a 5-yr old daughter.....I'm barely a parent LOL. Although, seeing how incredibly imaginative these kiddos are and how much joy they take from Christmas time it's hard to deny them that. In our house we don't play up Santa, but we don't squash it either. In our house it's about God, family, helping others and having some fun. A little Santa mixed in with the decorations, lights, hot chocolate, Peanuts Christmas special, etc.... is all good.
Now the gift part....yes, there are some things that come from Santa, but the majority and the big stuff....that's all Mommy and Daddy!
