No, the 5'10" has the better body, it's outrageous but her face is not great. The face on the smaller one is gorgeous. She's got F boobs as well (not as big as the 5'10" but HUGE by normal standards). I like the smaller one but she's only 18 (looks 22/23) . I'm meeting her Thurs/Fri again and she seems keen but at the end of the day I better not get attached...cos she's only 18.
First one: 10 body and 6(maybe 7) face
Second one: 9 body and 8/9 face
If she's gorgeous from the face then she wins. 5'5 phat and bodied blonds are damn hot. It's just that in the first pic she seemed to have soft ass, kinda droopy, but in the one that's side ways her ass looks phat, round and thick because she bends her legs. But 18 years old and if she's all that, then got get her! Why the hell would you get attached to her, because the sex might be too good? Just draw a pentagram under your bed, throw some salt and pepper on it and you're good

EDIT: I took another look, she doesn't have a droopy ass, it's just the quality of the photo. She's fine as hell