No, simply because he wrote an article titled "Cardio Makes You Fat", in which he, if I recall correctly, stated that moderate intensity cardio makes one fat and that because there are some people doing a lot of cardio but are still fat, then this leads to the genius conclusion that cardio is ineffective for fat loss.
That's like saying that weight training is ineffective for muscle building considering most who weight train look like shit or the same year after year, what is so for the majority of people that go to the gym.
I give him credit though. He has ingenuity and he has managed to amass a following of die-hard jock grabbers that behave as if their best friend is being insulted if you are not slavishly ingratiating of the man.
Example: "How dare you criticize John. He forgets more about bodybuilding than you will ever know! Let's see a picture. Have you won a pro card?!"
It's pretty funny.
