He deserved to win both.
2001 he was just waterlogged and got that out by the night show. On the video he still beats Jay easily. Pics are nice but video's or in person show so much more.
2002 I've seen the video, he is still the most muscular guy. Chad fucked him this show, he decided to get him down to 245 no matter what and put him on a all liquid diet. WTF??? He should just have dieted slowly down to 255 like he did at the AC 2001 and no-one would have said shit.