Steve Garvey was such a dullass personality but what a baller
p.s. The best all around athletes in basedull are.... Centerfielders and 3rd basemen
I wouldn't put a third baseman over a shortstop in terms of athletic ability. Sure, you have to have good reflexes, and a cannon of an arm, to be a good third baseman, but shortstops must have range and the athletic ability to turn a double play out of nowhere.
I'd say centerfielder, and shortstop.
Id also give special recognition to a great catcher. They are the coaches on the field, take immense wear and tear, and rarely get the kudos that they deserve.
Guys like Pudge Rodriguez don't fall from trees.