Is a liquor store owner to blame if someone came into their store as sober as can be, bought a large quantity of alcohol, went home, drank it, then drove back to the liquor store for more, but hit a pedestrian while driving under the influence in a drunk driving accident, severely injuring or even killing the pedestrian in the process?
I wouldn't blame the liquor store owner in that case. Unless he did something using horrible discretion in the process.
As far as bodybuilders are concerned, they were/are grown adults. They know that diuretics come with risks. I would even go so far as to say that most - especially at this point - are aware that they could potentially die due to cutting agents, specifically diuretics.
And that is why I simply cannot blame Chaicholls for the deaths of some of the heavy PED-using clients that he. Someone pointed out that some of his clients were massive and jacked before they met Chad- so it would be difficult to say how much blame Chad should be given in the decision.