Is HADI already better than PHIL has ever been ??

[affeman]

Was Phil overrated as a Mr O ?

[Humble Narcissist]

No.

[MAXX]

interesting with big arms like Phils in how in the fdb they can look the same or even worse but in the most muscular or relaxed they look so much better. Same with Levrones.

[wes]

Personally,I`m not a fan of either guy .

[joswift]

Was Phil overrated as a Mr O ?

the photo of phil is from the Arnold Classic and its after his abs had blown

Phils first Olympia was his best ever look and destroys Hadi

[Royalty]

The main problem with Getbig is that most of the idiots here have never attended an IFBB pro show.


They don’t even know what they are looking at..   they get wowed by filtered pics.



Heath is superior to Hadi in numerous ways. And it should be obvious to everyone.

[Pet shop boys]

Yes


woosshhhh

[obsidian]

Was Phil overrated as a Mr O ?

Heath by a mile in that comparison.

[Stephano]

lol, no, and it's not even close

Phil makes Hadi look like a grotesque dwarf.

[Wiggs]

Hell no.

[MAXX]

I'll say one thing and that is Hadi's midsection lifts his whole physique compared to Phils ugly troll gut. The vacuum looks better than the crunch too. That and I just think Hadi has a hardness from the front that Phil doesn't have.

From the back Phil probably dominates Hadi though

[illuminati]

Phil at his best & Hadi at his best - close call
Phil had the fuller rounder muscle bellies & better back
Hadi better condition & hardness & great vacuum shots

Either could win Take your pic.

[Stephano]

I'll say one thing and that is Hadi's midsection lifts his whole physique compared to Phils ugly troll gut. The vacuum looks better than the crunch too. That and I just think Hadi has a hardness from the front that Phil doesn't have.

From the back Phil probably dominates Hadi though

My man Phil didn't have a "troll gut" until very late in his career. 

Also, Phil has much better shape and flow than Hadi -- a better silhouette from the front and the back.  Way better side poses, too.

Hadi has always had shitty triceps and pointy delts.  He sucks.

[French]

Easy win for Hadi 2024.
Pictures are not on the same scale.
Hadi is too wide with another muscular dimension and dryness.
This was seen last year when Phil, who was big, was training with Hadi under Hani's supervision.
Seeing a live show is a different story than commenting on the image.
10 years have passed now.

[affeman]

Phil was basically all arms and shoulders, his entire torso was not even noteworthy

[Tarantula157]

Was Phil overrated as a Mr O ?

Just like with Dorian FDB wasn't Phil's best pose. Phil destroys Hadi from the back.

[AbrahamG]

Phil at his best & Hadi at his best - close call
Phil had the fuller rounder muscle bellies & better back
Hadi better condition & hardness & great vacuum shots

Either could win Take your pic.

Agreed.

[Bevo]

Overrated modern olympia winners would be Jay, Ramy, rhoden, Brandon curry

I would say the latter three were forgettable

[beakdoctor]

The main problem with Getbig is that most of the idiots here have never attended an IFBB pro show.


They don’t even know what they are looking at..   they get wowed by filtered pics.



Heath is superior to Hadi in numerous ways. And it should be obvious to everyone.

Nobody gives a fuck what opinion comes out of that dirty asshole you call a mouth. Fucking bozo still can't figure who won a show 44 years ago, thinks a dozen people are one guy,  aspy sense of humor, hand-fetish, weirgin (thats a combination of weirdo + virgin, lets call it the Royalty 80 combo)

[Humble Narcissist]

Nobody gives a fuck what opinion comes out of that dirty asshole you call a mouth. Fucking bozo still can't figure who won a show 44 years ago, thinks a dozen people are one guy,  aspy sense of humor, hand-fetish, weirgin (thats a combination of weirdo + virgin, lets call it the Royalty 80 combo)

[Dreadlifter]

I don't understand how this is even a question. Hadi has great conditioning but a horrible oil-filled goblin physique. Terrible Mr O. Phill had his flaws with his shoulder width, chest and gut later on, but he's still great and (narrow) shoulders above Hadi.

[oldschoolfan]

Hadi is also a goat 🐐 fucker and hates America he shouldn’t even be allowed in this country

[DanzigBrah]

Overrated modern olympia winners would be Jay, Ramy, rhoden, Brandon curry

I would say the latter three were forgettable

Hard to believe Shawn Rhodes died for us bitches 

[AbrahamG]

Hadi is also a goat 🐐 fucker and hates America he shouldn’t even be allowed in this country

Spoken like a true asshole.

[Bevo]

Spoken like a true asshole.

I’m willing to bet hadi has a larger cock than phil by miles