She's okay. I consider her the equivalent of a low end laptop at Staples. I can't name any of her songs except All I Want For Christmas. And that gets played over and over and over. She's an older woman now and does not belong in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame alongside legends like Darlene Love. I think her, Paula Abdul, Jennifer Lopez, Taylor Swift, and Katie Perry get way too much attention and praise when they aren't anything special. Carey has not earned her keep.
It sounds like you have a low opinion of Pop music and female pop musicians in general. Movies, music, and television are the primary art sources of the American culture and something we excel at.
The music industry if tough for women. They have a sell by date. Look at someone like Madonna who first launched in 1982. Even she says the most surprise thing about her is that she's still around. What's your opinion of Madonna?
I don't judge an artist by one thing they do, but by their entire history. If Madonna has a bad performance at the VMA's like she did this year, I don't judge her on that. Instead I judge her by everything she did since 1982 and it's impressive.
I'm not a Taylor Swift fan, but I recognize she currently the most important female artist and I see how she's done it. She will even show up to fans birthday parties.