I'm rewatching the 500k broadcast (Huge improvement from Friday night). In the final moments, they have Ronnie and Jay standing next to each other, Ronnie is shifting his weight from foot to foot and not facing the audience. he knew he was going down. It wasn't that close either. Flexonline shows that it was 38 to 22 with the lower score being better. Meanwhile Jay's face was filled with optimism and hope. Then after the sound of chic's voice announcing it.....he gets the nod.
Rewatch it and see for yourself.