Will 240 find some way to discredit Jay to promote the pdi?

[body88]

Hes trying baby!!!! Just needs somethin!!! Every second I come on here 240 is trying to indirectly call jays win bullshit and a fix. He was banking on Cutler getting screwed so he could push the Pdi as the fair place to be. Countless respected pros called jay the clear winner. Countless people at the show. The video seems to show Jay being the better man... All the fans who cheered and did not boo.


This coming from a PDI supporter in me also! I have supported it since day one.

I felt the show was scored and Judged fairly.
I saw the Prejudging and the top 6 were in the same order I saw on Friday Night.

From Milos

Official opinion is the same as I personally told Ronnie and Jay:

Jay DESERVED the victory....and I announced that already on Friday to many people that asked me for my opinion...

[240 is Back]

nah... i'm happy for jay... he deserved it in 2001 too.

[body88]

nah... i'm happy for jay... he deserved it in 2001 too.

I dont know bro. Seems that you are saying Ronnie was the winner and there was a fix in some threads. But in others saying you are happy for Cutler and he deserved it.

You have every right to your opinion. I just do not find the outcry by the Ronnie riders of pure bullshit fair. jay was better. Ronnie was off. We know Ronnie at 100 percent beats Jay. but he wasent and jay looked crazy. He won fair and square.

[240 is Back]

I think the sat night coleman would have won in prejudging and that the 2001 cutler had a much bigger advantage than the 2006 cuts did.  Also they both should have lost to melvin   But that's more judging consistency than anything else.  Jay winning is good for the sport, so it's good for the IFBB, good for next year's Mr O, good for the PDI, and good for those of us who build websites for Bbers

[body88]

I think the sat night coleman would have won in prejudging and that the 2001 cutler had a much bigger advantage than the 2006 cuts did.  Also they both should have lost to melvin   But that's more judging consistency than anything else.  Jay winning is good for the sport, so it's good for the IFBB, good for next year's Mr O, good for the PDI, and good for those of us who build websites for Bbers

I would go to a pdi show before I went to an IFBB show Rob. This coming from obviously a person very happy Cutler won the O. I still think the ifbb scan be shysters. If there is a pdi new england show I will most likley go to it.

Gets old when some people are acting like this win was like the O Franco won in the 80's. Ronnie was great but people need to accept he was off and lost to a better Cutler that night.

Can Cutler win it next year? I do not know. he did however deserve the win this past contest.

[mrsirjojo]

I think the sat night coleman would have won in prejudging and that the 2001 cutler had a much bigger advantage than the 2006 cuts did.  Also they both should have lost to melvin   But that's more judging consistency than anything else.  Jay winning is good for the sport, so it's good for the IFBB, good for next year's Mr O, good for the PDI, and good for those of us who build websites for Bbers

Everyone keeps saying that. What is good for the sport is everyone involved knowing that the best man, on a given night, will win. You can't reconcile someone winning when they shouldn't with it being "good for the sport".

[body88]

Everyone keeps saying that. What is good for the sport is everyone involved knowing that the best man, on a given night, will win. You can't reconcile someone winning when they shouldn't with it being "good for the sport".

Bodybuilding is subjective. YOU think he should have won. The judges, former greats like this and the entire audience thought differently.

I felt the show was scored and Judged fairly.
I saw the Prejudging and the top 6 were in the same order I saw on Friday Night.

From Milos

Official opinion is the same as I personally told Ronnie and Jay:

Jay DESERVED the victory....and I announced that already on Friday to many people that asked me for my opinion...

[Motorbreath]

I love it.....I am so happy for Jay. He rightfully deserved the win this year, as you can clearly see him OWNING Ronnie in the front lat spread photo above...

[mrsirjojo]

Bodybuilding is subjective. YOU think he should have won. The judges, former greats like this and the entire audience thought differently.

I never said who should have won, just that the better man should win.

[davidpaul]

jay looked incredible bottom line, if coleman was in condition in prejudging and dint have the tears etc, and smaller back, it was his, but jay was big and ripped, imo the one the best displays of back ever,

[Jr. Yates]

jay looked incredible bottom line, if coleman was in condition in prejudging and dint have the tears etc, and smaller back, it was his, but jay was big and ripped, imo the one the best displays of back ever,

I agree DP, jays back was incredable this year.