Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums

Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: the shadow on October 13, 2006, 11:54:46 AM

Title: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: the shadow on October 13, 2006, 11:54:46 AM
cutler has 2 votes for now..i know he is the greatest...and many more votes to come.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: jaejonna on October 13, 2006, 12:00:45 PM
Im sorry I hurt your feelings, I should of reminded myself that 'the shadow' would be completely devastated if I mentioned Jay Gutler among the worst BB of all time . My apologies, I guess your going to hate me from now on....get in line.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: body88 on October 13, 2006, 12:07:15 PM
I voted for Arnold. Should have voted for Cutler since I was pissed he lost to Ron in 2001. The Ronnie riders would have if Cutler was there God ::)
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: fearANDloathing on October 13, 2006, 01:32:20 PM

.....The greatest Olympian was just unfairly stripped of his title :'(
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: jaejonna on October 13, 2006, 01:34:57 PM
Flex Wheeler!!!
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: IceCold on October 13, 2006, 02:12:10 PM
arnold.

without him, there may not even be a mr. olympia or bbing after him.

who else has influenced as many people to take up bbing than arnold. 
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: knny187 on October 13, 2006, 03:12:35 PM
I voted Arnold.


He's the greatest....hands down
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: fathead on October 13, 2006, 03:38:25 PM
Victor Martinez       oh fuck wait i'm 2 years early my bad
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Hulkster on October 13, 2006, 03:42:00 PM
(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=75219.0;attach=82367;image)
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Rottmag on October 13, 2006, 03:46:06 PM
Flex Wheeler!!!

Ummm .. .. .. nevermind.

 ???
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Deadpool on October 13, 2006, 03:47:42 PM
arnold...he brought bodybuilding out of the backrooms and into the forefront
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Jr. Yates on October 13, 2006, 03:49:10 PM
arnold...he brought bodybuilding out of the backrooms and into the forefront
agreed.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: knny187 on October 13, 2006, 03:49:26 PM
arnold...he brought bodybuilding out of the backrooms and into the forefront


are you suggestion something medford?
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Slick Vic on October 13, 2006, 05:37:29 PM
'Nuff said.  ;D

(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/gallery/musclegallery1/ga10.jpg)
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: delta9mda on October 13, 2006, 05:45:59 PM
'Nuff said.  ;D

(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/gallery/musclegallery1/ga10.jpg)
chicken legs
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on October 13, 2006, 05:47:06 PM
The truly best Olympia is really Sergio Oliva but the one who used all of his tools to the best is Arnold and therefore got my vote for being a champion and not only looking like one.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: affy on October 13, 2006, 05:47:06 PM
greatest looking olympian is 98 coleman...its not even close...thats perfection

greatest olympian in general is ofcourse arnold
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Slick Vic on October 13, 2006, 06:01:01 PM
chicken legs

Naaaaaah....  ;D

(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/gallery/musclegallery2/xmg116.jpg)
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: knny187 on October 13, 2006, 06:22:50 PM
Arnold didn't have the biggest thighs...but it was in complete balance with his upper body
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: the shadow on October 13, 2006, 11:21:07 PM
i would sya it is a toss between ronnie coleman and jay..ronnie coleman dominanted this sport for 8 years and each year ronnie came in looking bigger and better..this guy set the bar so high that won't be reached  by any one.jay cutler should also be considered the greatest mr olympia cuz after 22yrs of stalemate ,cutler finally beats a reigning mr olympia.and the matter of fact that jay beat ronnie fair and square makes it even more impressive...long live jay and ronnie
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Hulkster on October 13, 2006, 11:33:27 PM
Quote
jay cutler should also be considered the greatest mr olympia cuz after 22yrs of stalemate ,cutler finally beats a reigning mr olympia.and the matter of fact that jay beat ronnie fair and square makes it even more impressive...

but is beating Ronnie at age 43 really that impressive?

seriously.

if Jay was as great as some on the board hype him up to be, he would have beat Ronnie a few years ago - eg in 2003.

In order for Jay to be considered as great as he is by some, he had to beat the best when they are at their best.

that has never happened.

Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Hulkster on October 13, 2006, 11:44:19 PM
the reason that I don't think that Jay beating Ronnie is not all that impressive is that its not like Jay has improved all that much and became good enough to beat Ronnie when Ronnie is in shape.

ronnie came up through the ranks, getting recognition in 96 but not really peaking until 1998 when he improved enough to start to kick ass.

 On the other hand, Jay peaked in 2001, and in 2006 showed up with a superwide waist, hardly any abs compared to before and a back that is still nothing to write home about.

and yet he won because Ronnie showed up looking horrible (but not bad considering most pros would have retired long ago).

the two are totally different situations.

Jay would have eared the hype if either he beat Ronnie when Ronnie was in shape or if his "new and improved" 2006 form would obviously have beat Ronnie when he was in his prime.

but that is not the case.

no one in their right mind believes that 2006 Jay could even come close to Ronnie at his best.

Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Figo on October 13, 2006, 11:51:51 PM
Arnold didn't have the biggest thighs...but it was in complete balance with his upper body

Absolutely!
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Figo on October 13, 2006, 11:54:43 PM
Which bber pre-Bannout, had the most impact and inluence on conditioning, a perfectly balanced physique, and set the precedent for shredded, ripped contest shape?

Before him, in comparison, everybody was smooth.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: nicorulez on October 14, 2006, 04:33:16 AM
but is beating Ronnie at age 43 really that impressive?

seriously.

if Jay was as great as some on the board hype him up to be, he would have beat Ronnie a few years ago - eg in 2003.

In order for Jay to be considered as great as he is by some, he had to beat the best when they are at their best.

that has never happened.



Exactly, Jay would have not even sniffed Ronnie's jock strap when he was in his thirties.  Ronnie of 1996 would have won this show.  Hell, Jay has about as much genetic gifts as a GE fridge.  Doz had awesome genetics; look at 1993 for confirmation of his greatness.  Ronnie was absolutely insane; best ever at his prime.  I would surmise that if he would have shown up in the shape he was in for the last GP show; he would have won.  Unfortunately for him, he was admittedly off and deserved to lose.  However, he should have beaten Jay and the judges gifted him that last show because they did not want their newly crowned Mr. O to taste defeat so soon.  Politics is a bitch.  Ronnie number one; Dorian number two and then Haney or Arnold.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Slick Vic on October 14, 2006, 05:38:01 AM
Arnold didn't have the biggest thighs...but it was in complete balance with his upper body

Exactly.... Thank you.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Slick Vic on October 14, 2006, 05:47:06 AM
Not only is Arnold Schwarzenegger the greatest Mr. Olympia ever, he's also the greates bodybuilder of the 20th century! The official recognition was given to Arnold by Ben Weider at the 1997 Arnold Classic when Ben gave him the "Gold Order of the IFBB".

Ben Weider: "It is a great pleasure to present this outstanding award to Arnold as the greatest of the 20th century. Afterall, the next medal will be presented 100 years from now." He added, "Arnold has the mind, the heart and the soul of a champion."

So there you have it. Don't you think that's saying a lot? I think so!  ;D
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Slick Vic on October 14, 2006, 05:51:04 AM
No it was not. His upper body (supersized chest, his delts and arms) overpowers his thighs/calves and not the best forearms. Arnolds perfect balance is a myth.

Here ya go. I thought you could use these to help you see....  :)

(http://www-assets.eyeglasses.com/dyn/frame_small/1060357061.jpg)
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: swilkins1984 on October 14, 2006, 06:01:11 AM
In terms of wins (undisputed)...Lee Haney.  There was only one Olympia where Lee was not at his absolute best (91 against Lee Labrada).  Great personality and a fitting champion.  Ronnie has the same number of wins as Haney but 2001 and 2002 were very controversial against Jay and Kevin Levrone respectively.  In terms of THE GREATEST overall,  Arnold Schwarzenegger because he was an almost unbeatable champion in his day and has given SO much back after his career ended.  From Austrian immigrant to champion bodybuilder to movie icon to contest promotor to Governor of California...no one will top that.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Tigerman on October 14, 2006, 06:09:06 AM
Arnold didn't have the biggest thighs...but it was in complete balance with his upper body

Your statement is absurd. Arnold was a great bodybuilder but he was not balanced. His pecs and arms were simply enormous, his legs in comparison were tiny. Bad and sloped shoulders jeopardized his simmetry as well.
However I admit he was a master at hiding flaws and at displaying his best poses. But the pictures we see today are always the ones where he looks better. For a bodybuilder today there is no chance to hide flaws, for each contest we can see hundreds of pictures.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Luv2Hurt on October 14, 2006, 06:31:09 AM
Arnold, not because of his physiqe, but everything else he brought.  Mainly charisma.............Arn ie has it anywhere in the world and more than all the other Mr. O's put together who dont even come close to him in that regaurd.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: ether on October 14, 2006, 06:36:24 AM
Arnold, not because of his physiqe, but everything else he brought.  Mainly charisma.............Arn ie has it anywhere in the world and more than all the other Mr. O's put together who dont even come close to him in that regaurd.

Arnold, because of his physique.

Huge arms, Massive Chest, Impressive delts and lats, and pretty decent legs for his era.

Not to mention the most impressive shoulder to waist taper ever.

(http://www.ironman-israel.com/gallery/schwarzenegger_arnold/ARNOLD25.JPG)

(http://www.ironman-israel.com/gallery/schwarzenegger_arnold/schwarzenegger_arnold_146.jpg)

HEIL ARNOLD!!!
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: delta9mda on October 14, 2006, 06:44:56 AM
Arnold didn't have the biggest thighs...but it was in complete balance with his upper body
no not really. youz be on dat crack as ronnies says. arnolds legs were not in balance or proportion to his upper body. get real.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: delta9mda on October 14, 2006, 06:48:20 AM
In terms of wins (undisputed)...Lee Haney.  There was only one Olympia where Lee was not at his absolute best (91 against Lee Labrada).  Great personality and a fitting champion.  Ronnie has the same number of wins as Haney but 2001 and 2002 were very controversial against Jay and Kevin Levrone respectively.  In terms of THE GREATEST overall,  Arnold Schwarzenegger because he was an almost unbeatable champion in his day and has given SO much back after his career ended.  From Austrian immigrant to champion bodybuilder to movie icon to contest promotor to Governor of California...no one will top that.
get it right, 89 or 90 haney had problems with flea and that was the drug tested show and lee was off.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: rayrod on October 14, 2006, 06:51:55 AM
In terms of wins (undisputed)...Lee Haney.  There was only one Olympia where Lee was not at his absolute best (91 against Lee Labrada).  Great personality and a fitting champion.  Ronnie has the same number of wins as Haney but 2001 and 2002 were very controversial against Jay and Kevin Levrone respectively.  In terms of THE GREATEST overall,  Arnold Schwarzenegger because he was an almost unbeatable champion in his day and has given SO much back after his career ended.  From Austrian immigrant to champion bodybuilder to movie icon to contest promotor to Governor of California...no one will top that.


there is a difference when Arnold competed against two or three people at each Olympia compared to Haney, Yates, and Coleman who are competing against 12 or more people.   Yes Arnold was great but these guys took it to the next level.    Arnold's body from his day wouldn't even place at the USA's or Nationals.    I'm sure if he competed now at his prime with todays advancements he would be one of the best.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: NarcissisticDeity on October 14, 2006, 07:55:03 AM
but is beating Ronnie at age 43 really that impressive?

seriously.

if Jay was as great as some on the board hype him up to be, he would have beat Ronnie a few years ago - eg in 2003.

In order for Jay to be considered as great as he is by some, he had to beat the best when they are at their best.

that has never happened.



If Ronnie was really as good as some on the board hype him up to be , he would have beat Dorian a few years ago - e.g 1996 lol you have to be carefull what you type slick

and Jay did beat Ronnie in both the symmetry and muscularity rounds of the 2001 Mr Olympia but Ronnie someone ' wins ' the whole contest with the posing rounds and mind you NO ONE in the history of the contest has ever lost the prejudging and won the contest with the posing rounds , Ronnie was a very lucky man

And for the record Arnold Schwarzenegger is the greatest Mr Olympia of all times , he was the standard bearer , he was the first to win six consecutive Mr Olympia titles , he could have won 14 if he wanted to , he retired at 28 and in all probablity never reached his full potential , he could have very easily won in 1976/77/78/79/81/82/83 Haney would have stopped him but he faced no one post his reign that he couldn't have beaten

And being the greatest Mr Olympia doesn't just encompass how many Sandows you have its more , Arnold went on to achive success that no one could have imagined and he still stayed true to his bodybuilding roots ( although thats changes because of his politics ) and he's done more for public exposure for bodybuilding than any former winner

Arnold is the original and the greatest !
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: sgt. d on October 14, 2006, 08:06:08 AM
I dont see why there are so many Arnold nut huggers on this thread. He is not the greatest Mr. Olympia of all time. Yes he did his little movies that made him famous but if arnold just competing in bbing and didnt do any acting then nobody would have heard of him(outside of bbing). The greatest Mr. Olympia should go to Lee Haney. Ronnie should be next......
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: NarcissisticDeity on October 14, 2006, 08:13:29 AM
I dont see why there are so many Arnold nut huggers on this thread. He is not the greatest Mr. Olympia of all time. Yes he did his little movies that made him famous but if arnold just competing in bbing and didnt do any acting then nobody would have heard of him(outside of bbing). The greatest Mr. Olympia should go to Lee Haney. Ronnie should be next......

Long before anyone heard of Haney or Ronnie there was Arnold , he set the standard for other to wish for 6 consecutive Mr Olympia wins and comming back in 1980 to win number 7 that was unheard of back then , so long before Arnold because famous in the movies he owned the sport of bodybuilding for a very long time , and could have won many more if he wanted to , hell the second best contest is the Arnold Classic , you add in all the rest of his accomplishments and only the naive would say he's not the best
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Slick Vic on October 14, 2006, 08:29:54 AM
I dont see why there are so many Arnold nut huggers on this thread. He is not the greatest Mr. Olympia of all time.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: JaggyShortBuff on October 14, 2006, 08:54:22 AM
Arnold will without a doubt have the most successful career in life of any Mr.Olympia of past, present, or future mark my words...The man is a true inspirational machine...
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Slick Vic on October 14, 2006, 09:23:03 AM
The man is a true inspirational machine...

That said it all right there.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: HERACLES on October 14, 2006, 09:45:55 AM
i would sya it is a toss between ronnie coleman and jay..ronnie coleman dominanted this sport for 8 years and each year ronnie came in looking bigger and better..this guy set the bar so high that won't be reached  by any one.jay cutler should also be considered the greatest mr olympia cuz after 22yrs of stalemate ,cutler finally beats a reigning mr olympia.and the matter of fact that jay beat ronnie fair and square makes it even more impressive...long live jay and ronnie

I would say your a fuking idiot. Jay won ONE mr O. Calm the hell down. Ronnie won 8. SOme of you are so fuking delusional its mind boggling.
"Toss between Jay and Ronnie" hahaha. I am a Cutler fan, but at the same time, you have to be real.  Jay is a great bodybuilder, but you morons taking away from Ronnie after finally losing a O (and its QUESTIONABLE ALSO) are a little extreme.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: HUGEPECS on October 14, 2006, 09:46:14 AM
I dont see why there are so many Arnold nut huggers on this thread. He is not the greatest Mr. Olympia of all time. Yes he did his little movies that made him famous but if arnold just competing in bbing and didnt do any acting then nobody would have heard of him(outside of bbing). The greatest Mr. Olympia should go to Lee Haney. Ronnie should be next......



I agree with you. Arnold was great, but imagine if his movie career failed, he would have just been another old fart who used to lift. His movie career put bodybuilding in the limelight, many said he was the greatest bodybuilder of all time.Ok, imagine him without being a big movie star. he probably would have own a couple gyms, His arnold classic, and whatever..
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: KTMckay on October 14, 2006, 10:06:06 AM
 :D
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: backday on October 14, 2006, 10:16:16 AM
Sergio is the man ;D
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on October 14, 2006, 10:19:27 AM
:D

Right on! Nobody can best him!
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: the shadow on October 14, 2006, 10:28:59 AM
CUTLER!!! CUTLER!!! CUTLER!!! CUTLER!!! CUTLER!!! CUTLER!!! CUTLER!!!
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Slick Vic on October 14, 2006, 10:41:27 AM
Right on! Nobody can best him!

Arnold-traitor!  :P
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on October 14, 2006, 10:42:16 AM
Arnold-traitor!  :P

haha I meant genetic wise. ;)
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: knny187 on October 14, 2006, 12:13:51 PM
No it was not. His upper body (supersized chest, his delts and arms) overpowers his thighs/calves and not the best forearms. Arnolds perfect balance is a myth.

I don't think so.

Arnold bicep's shape (height) was a gentic gift.  It was still in perfect proportion to his triceps.  His back was on par with his chest including delt tie ins. 

Quads & hams were balanced (not one bigger than the other & calves were in perfect size & condition to his upper leg development. 

In combination....his lower body was perfect with his upper body.

His faults (more than anything else) was his wide hips & lack of abdominal separations.  He posed in a manner always hiding his weak areas or in twisting shots to give the illusion of having a smaller waist to shoulder ratio.  This would automatically accentuate his upper body to seem sometimes much larger than his lower body.  When he stood in a straight-up front pose....you can tell his upper body totally matched his legs.

Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: suckmymuscle on March 01, 2007, 09:39:42 PM
If Ronnie was really as good as some on the board hype him up to be , he would have beat Dorian a few years ago - e.g 1996 lol you have to be carefull what you type slick

and Jay did beat Ronnie in both the symmetry and muscularity rounds of the 2001 Mr Olympia but Ronnie someone ' wins ' the whole contest with the posing rounds and mind you NO ONE in the history of the contest has ever lost the prejudging and won the contest with the posing rounds , Ronnie was a very lucky man

And for the record Arnold Schwarzenegger is the greatest Mr Olympia of all times , he was the standard bearer , he was the first to win six consecutive Mr Olympia titles , he could have won 14 if he wanted to , he retired at 28 and in all probablity never reached his full potential , he could have very easily won in 1976/77/78/79/81/82/83 Haney would have stopped him but he faced no one post his reign that he couldn't have beaten

And being the greatest Mr Olympia doesn't just encompass how many Sandows you have its more , Arnold went on to achive success that no one could have imagined and he still stayed true to his bodybuilding roots ( although thats changes because of his politics ) and he's done more for public exposure for bodybuilding than any former winner

Arnold is the original and the greatest !

  If we're going to be honest, Arnold did have some flaws: not all of his muscle bellies were long, his skeletal frame wasn't as perfect as Oliva's and he did have some muscular assymetries.

  However, and even though he was not genetically perfect, he was gifted enough which, when combined with his clinical approach to building his body, resulted in a physique that combined mass, proportions and aesthetics like no other. Arnold is the greatest ever, but not in terms o innate potential. If we're atalkig about innate genetic potential, then the greates bodybuilders of all times were, in no particular order:

 - Sergio Oliva

 - Kevin Levrone

 - Flex Wheeler

 - Aaron Backer

 - Denis Newman

 - Francis Benfatto

 - Phil Heath

  Chris Cormier could also have made that list, although I think his torso is a little long. Anyway, the men I mentioned are the only ones who had a close to perfect skeletal frame, combined with uniformaly long muscle bellies throughout their bodies.

  Now, Heath is another special case. He is vastly genetically superior to Cutler, but he won't be Mr.Olympia or a while because he needs to pile up at least 30 lbs of mass for that to happen. Now, if he can do that and maintain the crispness of details, hardness and symmetry that he displayed at the Colorado Pro Show, not only will he defeat Cutler with straight-firsts scores, but he will undoubtedly become the greatest Mr.Olympia of all times. The reason why I hesitate making a prediction is that lots of guys who look phenomenal at 230 or 240 lbs lose a lot of details, hardness when they go above 250 lbs, and they develop several symmetrical anomalies, such as gettig a distended gut. I Heath can control that, wow...he will have a physique that not even Fidias would be able to replicate On marble! :o

SUCKMYMUSCLE

 

 
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: pumpster on March 01, 2007, 10:24:04 PM
arnold.

without him, there may not even be a mr. olympia or bbing after him.

who else has influenced as many people to take up bbing than arnold. 

Now it's obvious that the frightening Yates ball-worship & warped views extend to Schwarzenegger-no Olympia without Arnold? LMAO

Schwarzenegger's thighs were undersized but with good presentation and in the context of  excellent shapes & cuts and alongside great calves, it worked. Wasn't a noticable shortcoming.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: ribonucleic on March 01, 2007, 10:28:36 PM
I know there's only one I would want to look like...

(http://www.classicbodybuilders.com/bodybuilder/frankzane/frankzane5.jpg)
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: pumpster on March 01, 2007, 10:31:28 PM
Not only is Arnold Schwarzenegger the greatest Mr. Olympia ever, he's also the greates bodybuilder of the 20th century! The official recognition was given to Arnold by Ben Weider at the 1997 Arnold Classic when Ben gave him the "Gold Order of the IFBB".

Ben Weider: "It is a great pleasure to present this outstanding award to Arnold as the greatest of the 20th century. Afterall, the next medal will be presented 100 years from now." He added, "Arnold has the mind, the heart and the soul of a champion."

So there you have it. Don't you think that's saying a lot? I think so!  ;D

Do you need kneepads to continue the worship?
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: bmacsys on March 02, 2007, 04:57:33 AM
  If we're going to be honest, Arnold did have some flaws: not all of his muscle bellies were long, his skeletal frame wasn't as perfect as Oliva's and he did have some muscular assymetries.

  However, and even though he was not genetically perfect, he was gifted enough which, when combined with his clinical approach to building his body, resulted in a physique that combined mass, proportions and aesthetics like no other. Arnold is the greatest ever, but not in terms o innate potential. If we're atalkig about innate genetic potential, then the greates bodybuilders of all times were, in no particular order:

 - Sergio Oliva

 - Kevin Levrone

 - Flex Wheeler

 - Aaron Backer

 - Denis Newman

 - Francis Benfatto

 - Phil Heath

  Chris Cormier could also have made that list, although I think his torso is a little long. Anyway, the men I mentioned are the only ones who had a close to perfect skeletal frame, combined with uniformaly long muscle bellies throughout their bodies.

  Now, Heath is another special case. He is vastly genetically superior to Cutler, but he won't be Mr.Olympia or a while because he needs to pile up at least 30 lbs of mass for that to happen. Now, if he can do that and maintain the crispness of details, hardness and symmetry that he displayed at the Colorado Pro Show, not only will he defeat Cutler with straight-firsts scores, but he will undoubtedly become the greatest Mr.Olympia of all times. The reason why I hesitate making a prediction is that lots of guys who look phenomenal at 230 or 240 lbs lose a lot of details, hardness when they go above 250 lbs, and they develop several symmetrical anomalies, such as gettig a distended gut. I Heath can control that, wow...he will have a physique that not even Fidias would be able to replicate On marble! :o

SUCKMYMUSCLE

 

 

How does Steve Reeves not make that list?
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Pollux on March 02, 2007, 10:24:56 AM
The greatest! Give it up for Arnold Schwarzenegger!


(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/gallery/musclegallery3/m191.jpg)
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: IceCold on March 02, 2007, 10:30:23 AM
Now it's obvious that the frightening Yates ball-worship & warped views extend to Schwarzenegger-no Olympia without Arnold? LMAO

Schwarzenegger's thighs were undersized but with good presentation and in the context of  excellent shapes & cuts and alongside great calves, it worked. Wasn't a noticable shortcoming.

more racism from our resident hater of any and all white bbers. 
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: swoody on March 02, 2007, 10:35:58 AM
For the sport: Schwarzenegger
From strictly a bodybuilding point of view: Coleman
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: kyomu on March 02, 2007, 10:42:29 AM
For the sport: Schwarzenegger
From strictly a bodybuilding point of view: Coleman
100%correct
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: donrhummy on March 02, 2007, 10:48:32 AM
From strictly a bodybuilding point of view: Coleman

How? Where does it say that a gut and undersized calves (and gyno) mean you're the peak of bodybuilding development?

From a strictly BB point of view, I'd say it has to be Sergio.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: pumpster on March 02, 2007, 10:49:36 AM
How does Steve Reeves not make that list?

Because dumbass, Reeves was never Mr. Olympia and no one but you fantasizes about sleeping with him.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: pumpster on March 02, 2007, 10:50:23 AM
more racism from our resident hater of any and all white bbers. 

It IS interesting that Icecold's ball-worship seems to center on white BBs.. ;) Borrow Vics kneepads and get to work homo.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: swoody on March 02, 2007, 10:54:12 AM
How? Where does it say that a gut and undersized calves (and gyno) mean you're the peak of bodybuilding development?

From a strictly BB point of view, I'd say it has to be Sergio.

Just stating my opinion... in 1999 and 2003 he was incredible.  Later on, yes he had a gut... and his calves were a tad underdeveloped... but as far as pushing the human body to the absolute brink, he takes it... he had his flaws, yes... but every O did.  And without any further intro, let the flaming/dorian vs ronnie war begin!!! ;D
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on March 02, 2007, 10:54:44 AM
Because dumbass, Reeves was never Mr. Olympia and no one but you fantasizes about sleeping with him.

Reeves won contest equivalent to the mr. Olympia. In his day he was the best!
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: kyomu on March 02, 2007, 10:56:40 AM
How? Where does it say that a gut and undersized calves (and gyno) mean you're the peak of bodybuilding development?

From a strictly BB point of view, I'd say it has to be Sergio.
Even if you have huge gut, you are forgiven if you have another bodyparts match.
Ronnie and Sergio is like Tree and weed.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: pumpster on March 02, 2007, 11:02:15 AM
Reeves won contest equivalent to the mr. Olympia. In his day he was the best!

Thanks for stating the obvious kid!
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on March 02, 2007, 11:03:39 AM
Thanks for stating the obvious kid!

No problem jabroni.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: hillbilly on March 02, 2007, 11:05:21 AM
i had to go with big Ron
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: swoody on March 02, 2007, 11:10:19 AM
From a standpoint of furthering the sport in the public eye and marketing, few will ever match Arnold's charisma. 
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: The Viking on March 02, 2007, 11:50:33 AM
The one and only Arnold,
fuck the legs. Have you seen todays bodybuilders walk?? They can`t.
Bannout in his prime also was a great bodybuilder.
And yes, I also thin Sergio was great.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: the shadow on March 02, 2007, 11:52:37 AM
The one and only Arnold,
fuck the legs. Have you seen todays bodybuilders walk?? They can`t.
Bannout in his prime also was a great bodybuilder.
And yes, I also thin Sergio was great.
yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: MRMD2003 on March 02, 2007, 03:00:17 PM
coleman 98' !!!!!!!  arnold is one of the greatest of all time while in his prime. however, he could beat coleman, haney, yates, levrone, or wheeler in their primes.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Pollux on March 02, 2007, 04:01:12 PM
coleman 98' !!!!!!!  arnold is one of the greatest of all time while in his prime. however, he could beat coleman, haney, yates, levrone, or wheeler in their primes.

You're right, he could.  ;D
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: ribonucleic on March 02, 2007, 04:03:27 PM
What part of "Frank 'Greatest Mr. Olympia Of All Time' Zane" don't you understand?

(http://www.classicbodybuilders.com/bodybuilder/frankzane/frankzane15.jpg)
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on March 02, 2007, 04:10:17 PM
What part of "Frank 'Greatest Mr. Olympia Of All Time' Zane" don't you understand?

(http://www.classicbodybuilders.com/bodybuilder/frankzane/frankzane15.jpg)

It would probably help if you posted a picture that works. If he is so good where did he place in this contest?
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: ribonucleic on March 02, 2007, 04:11:41 PM
I'll admit that Serge Nubret was even better.

But he wasn't Mr. Olympia.  :)
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on March 02, 2007, 04:13:07 PM
I'll admit that Serge Nubret was even better.

But he wasn't Mr. Olympia.  :)

Just Serge? What about Arnold and Sergio?
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Pollux on March 02, 2007, 04:16:50 PM
What part of "Frank 'Greatest Mr. Olympia Of All Time' Zane" don't you understand?

(http://www.classicbodybuilders.com/bodybuilder/frankzane/frankzane15.jpg)

The part where the box with the red X comes in.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: ribonucleic on March 02, 2007, 04:19:53 PM
Just Serge? What about Arnold and Sergio?

I think Frank had the more complete, aesthetic physique.

I concede it's a minority opinion.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on March 02, 2007, 04:20:51 PM
I think Frank had the more complete, aesthetic physique.

I concede it's a minority opinion.

You must be a tiny tit.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: ribonucleic on March 02, 2007, 04:22:26 PM
You must be a tiny tit.

I knew I wouldn't be able to say anything against Arnold without you trying to scratch my eyes out.  :-\
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on March 02, 2007, 04:24:08 PM
I knew I wouldn't be able to say anything against Arnold without you trying to scratch my eyes out.  :-\

There are 5 mr. Olympia competitors in that picture and you picked the smallest one.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: ribonucleic on March 02, 2007, 04:26:36 PM
There are 5 mr. Olympia competitors in that picture and you picked the smallest one.

I didn't pick Franco.  :)
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: alexxx on March 02, 2007, 04:28:24 PM
I didn't pick Franco.  :)

Franco is bigger than Zane. If Zane is not natural then that is the saddest thing.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: bmacsys on March 02, 2007, 04:36:28 PM
For the sport: Schwarzenegger
From strictly a bodybuilding point of view: Coleman

You are saying Ronnie Coleman has a better physique than Sergio Oliva did? NO WAY!
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: bmacsys on March 02, 2007, 04:37:41 PM
Because dumbass, Reeves was never Mr. Olympia and no one but you fantasizes about sleeping with him.



Pumpster, you are an idiot. I replied to this post moron.
   
   
Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....


  However, and even though he was not genetically perfect, he was gifted enough which, when combined with his clinical approach to building his body, resulted in a physique that combined mass, proportions and aesthetics like no other. Arnold is the greatest ever, but not in terms o innate potential. If we're atalkig about innate genetic potential, then the greates bodybuilders of all times were, in no particular order:

 - Sergio Oliva

 - Kevin Levrone

 - Flex Wheeler

 - Aaron Backer

 - Denis Newman

 - Francis Benfatto

 - Phil Heath

  Chris Cormier could also have made that list, although I think his torso is a little long. Anyway, the men I mentioned are the only ones who had a close to perfect skeletal frame, combined with uniformaly long muscle bellies throughout their bodies.

  Now, Heath is another special case. He is vastly genetically superior to Cutler, but he won't be Mr.Olympia or a while because he needs to pile up at least 30 lbs of mass for that to happen. Now, if he can do that and maintain the crispness of details, hardness and symmetry that he displayed at the Colorado Pro Show, not only will he defeat Cutler with straight-firsts scores, but he will undoubtedly become the greatest Mr.Olympia of all times. The reason why I hesitate making a prediction is that lots of guys who look phenomenal at 230 or 240 lbs lose a lot of details, hardness when they go above 250 lbs, and they develop several symmetrical anomalies, such as gettig a distended gut. I Heath can control that, wow...he will have a physique that not even Fidias would be able to replicate On marble! Shocked

SUCKMYMUSCLE

[/quote]


MOST OF THE GUYS ON HIS LIST WEREN'T MR. OLYMPIAS FAGBOY. DUH! PUT ON SOME GLASSES NERD.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: swoody on March 02, 2007, 04:53:37 PM
You are saying Ronnie Coleman has a better physique than Sergio Oliva did? NO WAY!

Aesthetically?  No... from a sheer bodybuilding standpoint of putting on the most amount of muscle and being as conditioned as possible?  Yes.  Just one white man's opinion ;D
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: bmacsys on March 02, 2007, 05:32:55 PM
Aesthetically?  No... from a sheer bodybuilding standpoint of putting on the most amount of muscle and being as conditioned as possible?  Yes.  Just one white man's opinion ;D

What about waist to shoulder differential? Proportions? Having calf development?
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: NeoSeminole on March 02, 2007, 06:13:00 PM
in terms of who would win a bodybuilding contest, then Ronnie >>> all

(http://i60.photobucket.com/albums/h29/NeoSeminole/Ronnie%20Coleman/rc104.jpg)

(http://i60.photobucket.com/albums/h29/NeoSeminole/Ronnie%20Coleman/2001ASC-RonnieColeman61.jpg)

(http://i60.photobucket.com/albums/h29/NeoSeminole/Ronnie%20Coleman/2001ASC-RonnieColeman57.jpg)

(http://i60.photobucket.com/albums/h29/NeoSeminole/Ronnie%20Coleman/2001ASC-RonnieColeman32.jpg)

(http://i60.photobucket.com/albums/h29/NeoSeminole/Ronnie%20Coleman/2001ASC-RonnieColeman54.jpg)
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: bmacsys on March 02, 2007, 06:31:38 PM
in terms of who would win a bodybuilding contest, then Ronnie


Your trying to tell me Coleman ever could hold a candle to this man?
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: NeoSeminole on March 02, 2007, 06:39:45 PM
Your trying to tell me Coleman ever could hold a candle to this man?

yes. Don't get me wrong, Sergio Oliva is my fav. bodybuilder of all-time. However, even as a huge fan of his physique I must admit that he never reached the level of conditioning required to win against a Dorian Yates or Ronnie Coleman. If Sergio had access to today's drugs and nutrition experts, then I have no doubts that he would easily be the greatest ever.
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: suckmymuscle on March 03, 2007, 02:58:49 AM


Pumpster, you are an idiot. I replied to this post moron.
   
   
Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....


  However, and even though he was not genetically perfect, he was gifted enough which, when combined with his clinical approach to building his body, resulted in a physique that combined mass, proportions and aesthetics like no other. Arnold is the greatest ever, but not in terms o innate potential. If we're atalkig about innate genetic potential, then the greates bodybuilders of all times were, in no particular order:

 - Sergio Oliva

 - Kevin Levrone

 - Flex Wheeler

 - Aaron Backer

 - Denis Newman

 - Francis Benfatto

 - Phil Heath

  Chris Cormier could also have made that list, although I think his torso is a little long. Anyway, the men I mentioned are the only ones who had a close to perfect skeletal frame, combined with uniformaly long muscle bellies throughout their bodies.

  Now, Heath is another special case. He is vastly genetically superior to Cutler, but he won't be Mr.Olympia or a while because he needs to pile up at least 30 lbs of mass for that to happen. Now, if he can do that and maintain the crispness of details, hardness and symmetry that he displayed at the Colorado Pro Show, not only will he defeat Cutler with straight-firsts scores, but he will undoubtedly become the greatest Mr.Olympia of all times. The reason why I hesitate making a prediction is that lots of guys who look phenomenal at 230 or 240 lbs lose a lot of details, hardness when they go above 250 lbs, and they develop several symmetrical anomalies, such as gettig a distended gut. I Heath can control that, wow...he will have a physique that not even Fidias would be able to replicate On marble! Shocked

SUCKMYMUSCLE




MOST OF THE GUYS ON HIS LIST WEREN'T MR. OLYMPIAS FAGBOY. DUH! PUT ON SOME GLASSES NERD.

  Did I say they were standard-bearers, you moron? No. I said these were the bodybuilders who had the most innate genetic potential or bodybuilding, exemplified by having a perect skeletal frame and long muscle bellies.

  I think you're just upset about how badly I owned you at the Hugo Chavez thread on the general topics boards. What a waste of time you are or me. Loser.

SUCKMYMUSCLE
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: bmacsys on March 03, 2007, 04:57:18 AM
  Did I say they were standard-bearers, you moron? No. I said these were the bodybuilders who had the most innate genetic potential or bodybuilding, exemplified by having a perect skeletal frame and long muscle bellies.

  I think you're just upset about how badly I owned you at the Hugo Chavez thread on the general topics boards. What a waste of time you are or me. Loser.

SUCKMYMUSCLE


Dude, I don't know if this was addressed to me but I WAS REFERRING TO PUMPSTER YOU ROTTEN TOOTH ENGLISH FUCKWIT! You haven't owned anybody on GetBig so get over yourself. What happens is you get hammered and then disapear for a month and then  work up your courage to post again so shut the fuck up retard.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Hulkster on March 03, 2007, 05:46:37 AM
that was beautiful.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: RocketSwitch625 on March 03, 2007, 01:30:46 PM
Ronnie Coleman is the greatest Mr. Olympia of all time and here are some pictures to prove it to the world:

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87891;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87820;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87892;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87899;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87907;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87932;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87933;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87942;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87943;image)

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87944;image)




Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: ribonucleic on March 03, 2007, 01:38:07 PM
(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87820;image)

That's the most iconic bodybuilding picture of the decade.  :(
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: NeoSeminole on March 03, 2007, 02:03:30 PM
Dude, I don't know if this was addressed to me but I WAS REFERRING TO PUMPSTER YOU ROTTEN TOOTH ENGLISH FUCKWIT! You haven't owned anybody on GetBig so get over yourself. What happens is you get hammered and then disapear for a month and then  work up your courage to post again so shut the fuck up retard.

ownage. 8)
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: SWOLETRAIN on March 03, 2007, 02:18:44 PM
this is gonna be another truce thread isnt it?... ::)
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: mesmorph78 on March 03, 2007, 02:52:34 PM
yep
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: suckmymuscle on March 04, 2007, 08:31:30 AM

Dude, I don't know if this was addressed to me but I WAS REFERRING TO PUMPSTER YOU ROTTEN TOOTH ENGLISH FUCKWIT! You haven't owned anybody on GetBig so get over yourself. What happens is you get hammered and then disapear for a month and then  work up your courage to post again so shut the fuck up retard.

  Then why did you quote my post, guy? Are you so fucking stupid that you can't even quote the right poster? Moron. And by the way, who said that I ran away for a month? None of you twits replied to my posts, so I thought the issue was over. Yeah, I'm scared of the big bad geek boy shouting in caps over his computer screen. ;D

SUCKMYMUSCLE
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: bmacsys on March 04, 2007, 08:48:30 AM
  Then why did you quote my post, ####? Are you so fucking stupid that you can't even quote the right poster? Moron. And by the way, who said that I ran away for a month? None of you twits replied to my posts, so I thought the issue was over. Yeah, I'm scared of the big bad geek boy shouting in caps over his computer screen. ;D

SUCKMYMUSCLE

Who asked you to be scared dork?
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: bmacsys on March 04, 2007, 08:52:07 AM
(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=69359.0;attach=87820;image)

That's the most iconic bodybuilding picture of the decade.  :(


I just don't how see todays guys like Coleman with a huge gut are a step forward from this-
Title: Re: WHO is THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: suckmymuscle on March 04, 2007, 08:59:18 AM
Who asked you to be scared dork?

  Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha...you take the trophy for stupidest Getbig.com member ever. You can't even quote the poster you're replying to! ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D. Bwa ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha...what a fucking retard! ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D

SUCKMYMUSCLE


 
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: swoody on March 04, 2007, 01:20:22 PM
What about waist to shoulder differential? Proportions? Having calf development?

I ain't gonna argue with ya bud, its just my opinion and I'm sticking to it... respect that.  I respect your opinion about Olivia... the dude truely is a "myth".  If he were on the drugs these guys are on today, he would wipe the field out completely, including Coleman. He is much more aesthetically pleasing to the eye, and should be considered one of the true legendary greats. But I aint gonna make this another rediculous ronnie VS whoever thread...  It was two different eras of bodybuilding... you can't compare them.  They were both the greatest in their era, and each era is different.  Its kind of like comparing wilt chamberlain to michael jordan... both are considered the best basketball player ever, but it was two different eras... you can't compare the two.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: pobrecito on March 04, 2007, 01:23:37 PM
Dorian is the greatest Mr. Olympia....just look at these pictures:
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: swoody on March 04, 2007, 01:27:32 PM
On second thought, I think we should just copy/paste this entire thread and crop it onto the "truce" thread... cause that's basically what it is... a bunch of stuborn egos not respecting other peoples opinion on who is the "greatest ever".  Its a rediculous discussion and no one can ever prove who the greatest was simply by comparing bad photos to good photos.
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: Hulkster on March 04, 2007, 01:51:06 PM
Dorian is the greatest Mr. Olympia....just look at these pictures:

I see smooth people.... ;)
Title: Re: WHO IS THE GREATEST MR OLYMPIA OF ALL TIME....
Post by: tu_holmes on March 04, 2007, 01:53:04 PM
I'm always saying
Franco is bigger than Zane. If Zane is not natural then that is the saddest thing.

Size wise... Zane was the lightest Mr. O ever... at like 180 pounds.

My vote goes to Sergio... the GOAT.