Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: Mr Nobody on December 25, 2009, 11:41:19 AM
-
Top 3 Mr Olympia's of all time.
1. Arnold
2. Ronnie
3. Dorrian
Now you have to take into consideration the difference in years and drug science for the years at which they won the title.
Discuss.
-
Top 3 Mr Olympia's of all time.
1. Arnold
2. Ronnie
3. Dorrian
Now you have to take into consideration the difference in years and drug science for the years at which they won the title.
Discuss.
oh brother
-
Dorian
Arnold
Haney
-
Ronnie
Haney
Arnold
-
Arnold
Ronnie
Haney
-
Ronnie
Haney
Arnold
Wiggs I call racist on your picks
-
Wiggs I call racist on your picks
I was gonna call racist on some other pics but decided to be racist myself... ;D
-
1 Ronnie, 2 Dorian, 3 Jay
I never understood that Arnold hype. Back in the days he was one of the best, but conditioning & proportion wise he doesn't deserve a all time top 3 placing. Only reasons for his popularly I can find is the way he represented BB & his charisma.
-
1 Ronnie, 2 Dorian, 3 Jay
I never understood that Arnold hype. Back in the days he was one of the best, but conditioning & proportion wise he doesn't deserve a all time top 3 placing. Only reasons for his popularly I can find is the way he represented BB & his charisma.
Plates I have to disagree, the dude was in the 70's huge ass arms and chest. I know if he was in the Mr O today in his shape then he wouldnt win but you got to consider the drug advances and such.
-
Arnold was farther ahead of his competition during his time than even Ronnie and Haney during theirs. That is the proper way to judge them. Few even remember who finished second to Arnold he was so far ahead of the pack.
-
1. Easily Arnold, small waist, good muscle bellies and a near perfect physique considering his time
2. Ronnie
3. Yates!
-
1. Easily Arnold, small waist, good muscle bellies and a near perfect physique considering his time
2. Ronnie
3. Yates!
1234 is a smart man
-
Plates I have to disagree, the dude was in the 70's huge ass arms and chest.
He sure had some serious guns, but his bicep/tricep development was way out of proportions. The same for his arms/legs, and waist/torso. The striations in his chest were only visable during a most muscular.
I know if he was in the Mr O today in his shape then he wouldnt win but you got to consider the drug advances and such.
I agree that more efficient PED's are in advance for todays pro's, but -for example- Zane (no, not a typical favorite of mine) had a much better conditioning.
-
Arnold was farther ahead of his competition during his time than even Ronnie and Haney during theirs. That is the proper way to judge them. Few even remember who finished second to Arnold he was so far ahead of the pack.
In case it's a all time comparison you need to compare Ronnie with Arnold, not Ronnie with Phil Heath or Arnold with Mike Mentzer
-
In case it's a all time comparison you need to compare Ronnie with Arnold, not Ronnie with Phil Heath or Arnold with Mike Mentzer
So how do we compare?
-
So how do we compare?
Serious question? LOL
I thought we were comparing Mr O's to decide our personal top3, but I could be wrong ::)
-
Serious question? LOL
I thought we were comparing Mr O's to decide our personal top3, but I could be wrong ::)
Yes from your last post it seems we cant compare? I think we can but take into consideration the times of each Mr O and competion factors. So in the Arnold years he didnt have the competion of today but didnt have the drugs of today either so if we give him the drugs of today and face the competion would he win?
-
Sincerely Arnolds physique cant beat those phsiques of Haney, Yates, Coleman, Dexter and Cutler.
If we talk about greatest, i understand that you guys include him in top 3.
But, if you include Arnold physique as top 3, seriously you dont know bbing.
-
If Arnold were competing today he would still be a multiple time Mr. Olympia. He would use the same drugs, advances in nutrition and equipment that are available to the guys competing today and he would crush them the same way he did the guys back in the 70s.
All things being equal Arnold would simply "will" his way to victory. What Arnold has inside that drives him can't be defeated. He simply won't allow himself to lose. It's why he's accomplished things nobody ever dreamed he could.
-
If Arnold were competing today he would still be a multiple time Mr. Olympia. He would use the same drugs, advances in nutrition and equipment that are available to the guys competing today and he would crush them the same way he did the guys back in the 70s.
All things being equal Arnold would simply "will" his way to victory. What Arnold has inside that drives him can't be defeated. He simply won't allow himself to lose. It's why he's accomplished things nobody ever dreamed he could.
X2
-
Sincerely Arnolds physique cant beat those phsiques of Haney, Yates, Coleman, Dexter and Cutler.
If we talk about greatest, i understand that you guys include him in top 3.
But, if you include Arnold physique as top 3, seriously you dont know bbing.
So who is your top 3 kyomu?
-
Yes from your last post it seems we cant compare?
No, I won't say that. It's just a different point of view and that's ok with me.
I think we can but take into consideration the times of each Mr O and competion factors. So in the Arnold years he didnt have the competion of today but didnt have the drugs of today either so if we give him the drugs of today and face the competion would he win?
I see your topic more as a virtual pose down. I agree that this could be a unfair comparison because of more effective PED's, supplements, foods, gyms, knowledge and other factors these days. But hey, you were the topic starter ;)
-
If Arnold were competing today he would still be a multiple time Mr. Olympia. He would use the same drugs, advances in nutrition and equipment that are available to the guys competing today and he would crush them the same way he did the guys back in the 70s.
All things being equal Arnold would simply "will" his way to victory. What Arnold has inside that drives him can't be defeated. He simply won't allow himself to lose. It's why he's accomplished things nobody ever dreamed he could.
Only with much better proportions and this is much more a genetic thing.
-
Since we all agree Arnold is the best the real arguement should be who should be second, Ronnie or Dorian.
-
Since we all agree Arnold is the best the real arguement should be who should be second, Ronnie or Dorian.
Looks like Arnold inspired you with his Oliva mind war tricks ;)
-
Haney was more significant than Dorian.
-
In order...
Arnold
Sergio
Lee
-
Levrone, Flex then Shawn Ray
-
Levrone, Flex then Shawn Ray
Agree with Flex and Shawn :)
-
Top 3 Mr Olympia's of all time.
1. Arnold
2. Ronnie
3. Dorrian
Now you have to take into consideration the difference in years and drug science for the years at which they won the title.
Discuss.
dorian
haney
samir
-
Ronnie
Arnold
Haney
HTTP://WWW.PHYSIQUEBOOK.COM
-
1. Easily Arnold, small waist, good muscle bellies and a near perfect physique considering his time
2. Ronnie
3. Yates!
Good post..
-
Ronnie
Arnold
Yates
Anyone who chooses Haney over Yates is racist. Monster 15 inch arms and 22 inch legs.
-
Haney was more significant than Dorian.
How? Dorian influenced a whole era of BBs to stop training each body part 2 -3 times a week directly and cut back on volume but increase the intensity.
This wasnt new as many others had been saying to train this way for a long time but no one listened till dozer spoke.
What did haney do that had a mass following from what he said?
-
Ronnie
Arnold
Yates
Anyone who chooses Haney over Yates is racist. Monster 15 inch arms and 22 inch legs.
Haney beat Dorian regardless. Sure, Dorian hadn't reached his peak and Lee had just hit his prime, but considering the vast difference in juice and GH that catapulted in the 90's after that, Haney owned Dorian.
-
Haney beat Dorian regardless. Sure, Dorian hadn't reached his peak and Lee had just hit his prime, but considering the vast difference in juice and GH that catapulted in the 90's after that, Haney owned Dorian.
ok, i really dont give a fvck either way.
-
Arnold from 1970-83 with the age of huge size and cuts and Dorian from 1992-1997 with the new age of massive muscularity and conditioning....hard to separate Lee and Ronnie for the top 3 who also both dominated their eras with incredible physiques
-
Hulkster and NarsissisticDeity, imma let you finish, but Arnold had one of the best bodies of all time. Of ALL time.
-
Arnold, Levrone and Flex (maybe Shawn in there somewhere too)
-
Dorian, Arnold, Cutler
-
Sincerely Arnolds physique cant beat those phsiques of Haney, Yates, Coleman, Dexter and Cutler.
If we talk about greatest, i understand that you guys include him in top 3.
But, if you include Arnold physique as top 3, seriously you dont know bbing.
We dont know BBing?
oh brother
shut up fool.....you compete, so somehow your knowledge is umero uno......dickweed
the OP said taken in context.....capeich?
anyway, Arnold wins without doubt.....he was so far ahead of the curve, that had he kept going he could of had 12/13 Olympias.....would have takten until the size and qiality of Haney to challenge him
-
We dont know BBing?
oh brother
shut up fool.....you compete, so somehow your knowledge is umero uno......dickweed
the OP said taken in context.....capeich?
anyway, Arnold wins without doubt.....he was so far ahead of the curve, that had he kept going he could of had 12/13 Olympias.....would have takten until the size and qiality of Haney to challenge him
Absolutely no idea.
Its crystal clear that you cant even judge 7 mandatory poses.
Arnold dont have whole lower body comparing with another.
And his muscles are too soft to compare with others.
His delts are very weka comparing with others.
Why his waist is small? Because he doesnt have complete back and huge lower body,thats the real reason.
-
So who is your top 3 kyomu?
If we talk about comparing their physiques only,
1,Ronnie
2,Jay
3,Dorian
Note: Nothing to do with my favourite. Just i imagine if they are on same stage and hitting all the 7 mandatory poses.
Maybe some says that Jay cant beat Dorian. But Jay(2009) destroys Dorian with 5 poses of 7 mandatorys(2 are back poses).
-
Franco, Dexter, Arnold 1980
-
If we talk about comparing their physiques only,
1,Ronnie
2,Jay
3,Dorian
Note: Nothing to do with my favourite. Just i imagine if they are on same stage and hitting all the 7 mandatory poses.
Maybe some says that Jay cant beat Dorian. But Jay(2009) destroys Dorian with 5 poses of 7 mandatorys(2 are back poses).
I dont think Jay can beat Dorrian in back poses, maybe double bicep for sure from the front.
-
I dont think Jay can beat Dorrian in back poses, maybe double bicep for sure from the front.
Thats what i am saying.
Dorian beat jay completely from back. But that is only 2 poses.
But Jay beat Dorian from the front. Ah.... Also Dorian beats jay with his side tris. Dorians side tris is a master piece.
So
Jay 4- Dorian 3
Jay win against Dorian.
-
Absolutely no idea.
Its crystal clear that you cant even judge 7 mandatory poses.
Arnold dont have whole lower body comparing with another.
And his muscles are too soft to compare with others.
His delts are very weka comparing with others.
Why his waist is small? Because he doesnt have complete back and huge lower body,thats the real reason.
Yes maybe you have a point.But how big would bodybuilders today be if their stomachs and waistline was like Arnolds? They have bigger muscles but the stomachs are disgusting, and im sure if Arnold pumped all that GH he would be as big as any bodybuilder today.
Your point sucks ;)
-
Yes maybe you have a point.But how big would bodybuilders today be if their stomachs and waistline was like Arnolds? They have bigger muscles but the stomachs are disgusting, and im sure if Arnold pumped all that GH he would be as big as any bodybuilder today.
Your point sucks ;)
Then Bob paris will kick ass of arnold.
His waist line is thinner and more beautiful hah?
But why Bob cant beat arnold? Because he has less mass than arnold. Bodybuilding is about muscle.
And your point certainly sucks. I didnt say WHO IS GREATER. But I said WHO HAS(Had) THE BEST PHYSIQUE in terms of bbing competition. You are messing two those things.
So my greatest Mr.O ranking is.
1 Arnold
2. haney
3.Ronnie
-
Franco, Dexter, Arnold 1980
Epic joke
-
So my greatest Mr.O ranking is.
1 Arnold
2. haney
3.Ronnie
You said in another post Arnold couldnt possibly be in the top 3 ???
-
You said in another post Arnold couldnt possibly be in the top 3 ???
Maybe 'greatest' and 'best' are on the same page in your dictionary...
-
If Arnold were competing today he would still be a multiple time Mr. Olympia. He would use the same drugs, advances in nutrition and equipment that are available to the guys competing today and he would crush them the same way he did the guys back in the 70s.
All things being equal Arnold would simply "will" his way to victory. What Arnold has inside that drives him can't be defeated. He simply won't allow himself to lose. It's why he's accomplished things nobody ever dreamed he could.
Exactly. The list goes like this,
1. Arnold
2. everyone else
-
can we add the uncrowned mr. olympia :-X
-
You said in another post Arnold couldnt possibly be in the top 3 ???
I explain it to you.
GREATEST and BEST PHYSIQUE are TWO DIFFERENT THING.
Greatest means: A mr.o who give great impact and influence to the bodybuilding society and even genral society.
Best physique means:A mr.o who dominate a bodybuilding contest in which they(All mr.o) are on stage together and hit 7 mandatories. There,they count MASS, CUT and SHAPE and complete physique strictly.
-
can we add the uncrowned mr. olympia :-X
Strictly saying NO.
-
jay wins front double bicep, side chest, most musc..
dorian easily wins abbs n thigh, side tricep, back double bi, rear lat spread, front lat spread.. dorian rapes him on conditioning too
arnold, yates, ronny..........
others were insignifcant in real terms..
-
1-Arnold
2-Haney
3-Zane
4-Oliva
5-Scott
6-Bannout
7-Cutler
8-Coleman
9-Yates
10-Jackson
11-Dickerson
12-Columbu
-
Ronnie
Arnold
Yates
Anyone who chooses Haney over Yates is racist. Monster 15 inch arms and 22 inch legs.
I did and I am a white guy
-
Top 3 Mr Olympia's of all time.
1. Arnold
2. Ronnie
3. Dorrian
Now you have to take into consideration the difference in years and drug science for the years at which they won the title.
Discuss.
1. coleman and arnold because he is bodybuilding
2. beautiful man with glasses
3. dorian
-
I think Dorian was best in 1993 although I still argue Arnold was best of all time given all factors.
-
A question.
What is the defenition of "Best"?
-
A question.
What is the defenition of "Best"?
A Beast is just a statement in the video = usually means a monster that will tear you apart best I can explain. 8)
-
A question.
What is the defenition of "Best"?
Good question because this qualification seems to be debatable over here.
In this particular case the highest overall score, just like a normal BB competition.
-
A Beast is just a statement in the video = usually means a monster that will tear you apart best I can explain. 8)
Sorry, I am a fool and i dont understand even 1% meaning of this sentence. ;D
Explain it again please.
-
I was gonna call racist on some other pics but decided to be racist myself... ;D
ronald
haney
dickerson :-\
true story
-
Sorry, I am a fool and i dont understand even 1% meaning of this sentence. ;D
Explain it again please.
Beast = an animal difficult to control or deal with.
-
Beast = an animal difficult to control or deal with.
So, arnold= beast? ???
-
So, arnold= beast? ???
;D Yes :D When is dinner with 90% women?
-
So, arnold= beast? ???
He has the nomenclature of a Neanderthal :-\
-
Arnold was farther ahead of his competition during his time than even Ronnie and Haney during theirs. That is the proper way to judge them. Few even remember who finished second to Arnold he was so far ahead of the pack.
I wouldn't say Arnold was head and shoulders ahead of Sergio or Nubret. Those three were the 70's icons. Forget Ferrigno or Franco, good yes, elite no.
-
;D Yes :D When is dinner with 90% women?
Within 1hr.
But I dont feel going now...
I saw all the pic of them and look boring and ugly. :-\
I saw them in facebook. And their comment show that their personality is quite boring. :-\
-
Within 1hr.
But I dont feel going now...
I saw all the pic of them and look boring and ugly. :-\
I saw them in facebook. And their comment show that their personality is quite boring. :-\
Sorry man stay home and watch Pumping Iron. Arnold has some good views on women.
-
I would say arnold is head and shoulders above everyone. He had a strong personality
Haney,coleman,yates were less colorful.
-
Ronnie
Arnold
Yates
Anyone who chooses Haney over Yates is racist. Monster 15 inch arms and 22 inch legs.
Oh, I forgot just how great Dorian's arms were ::) ::) ::) ::) ::) ::) ::) ::) ::) ::) ::) ::)
-
I would say arnold is head and shoulders above everyone. He had a strong personality
Haney,coleman,yates were less colorful.
He knew how to play the game, now I think he was a bit of a asshole but look where he is now governor of California.
-
in no particular order cutler, yates and haney
-
ronald
haney
dickerson :-\
true story
Now Parker has has a interesting entry = Dickerson to me had good legs but the upper body was small but a classic physique I wouldnt have him top 3 not taking away from him, he was along the lines of Zane which popular around that time..great poser.
-
I dont think Jay can beat Dorrian in back poses, maybe double bicep for sure from the front.
Not to be a dick, but Dorian has ONE r in his name, NOT two. Why do you keep misspelling his name when you see everyone spelling it correctly?
-
I explain it to you.
GREATEST and BEST PHYSIQUE are TWO DIFFERENT THING.
Greatest means: A mr.o who give great impact and influence to the bodybuilding society and even genral society.
Best physique means:A mr.o who dominate a bodybuilding contest in which they(All mr.o) are on stage together and hit 7 mandatories. There,they count MASS, CUT and SHAPE and complete physique strictly.
Aside from Arnold, NO other bodybuilder has EVER had great impact, or ANY impact on society in general.
-
Not to be a dick, but Dorian has ONE r in his name, NOT two. Why do you keep misspelling his name when you see everyone spelling it correctly?
Thanks man I have been fucking up spelling lately
-
jay wins front double bicep, side chest, most musc..
dorian easily wins abbs n thigh, side tricep, back double bi, rear lat spread, front lat spread.. dorian rapes him on conditioning too
arnold, yates, ronny..........
others were insignifcant in real terms..
Dorian SLAUGHTERS Jay in side chest. NO FUCKING CONTEST.
Jay looks like dogshit. SOOOO overhyped for todays new generation. Size does NOT equal quality, especially when it's in the shape of a fridge with NO veins.