The top pic is a Brian Moss; the bottom, the great Amir Marandi.
Now, which pic presents the lovely Ms. Searles in a better light?
Personally, I like the styling of the first one better. It's supposed to be voyueristic and make you think you're not supposed to be seeing those kinds of images. If Jen didn't want photos like that, she wouldn't have shot with him. I've seen some of Moss' stuff cross the line from voyuer to, well, porntastic.. but most of his stuff stays away from that proverbial line.
And yeah, rough/raw images can look cool if they are styled right. Two photographers can take a photo in front of a generic wall with the same model and come out with two very different looking images. It just depends on your ideas going into it. For example, here's a photo I took ::coughshamelessplugcough:: of MJ Cooke in front of a generic, somewhat grimy, wall.