It is very confusing indeed, but it's always subjective, and that's just the way it is. Taking nothing away from Cathy, of course...she looked fantastic, and it's always nice to see a "smaller" fbb win the show. I just think that Luv and I are very partial to Annie. 
Yeah Rip we are big Annie fans
Yes Annie needs to come into shows a touch harder but I still think she had by far the most asthetic physiqe in that show by far. Great lines. Man I still dont see how the winner could score 10 in the first 2 rounds (symetry and muscularity) and Annie could get 60?
The sport is VERY subjective. But still looking at the pics I just dont get what the judges are looking at. I mean conditioning should not be the only thing, no insult to the other girls but the top placers IMO have major structural flaws that should be scored down.
Oh well, my favorite Annie shot from the show. Annie has sleek shapely lines from the front and from the side has awesome thickness, check out the delts, especially the rear delt
