Batista
Is this guy someone who has turned his life around, from a teenager likely heading to jail, to being one of the biggest superstars of his generation? Despite coming into the business at a relatively old age, has he never looked back, always striving to make himself a success. In Evolution, was he part of one of the best stables of the past decade? And will his charisma and personality allow him to be successful in whatever he decides to do in the future?
OR
Is he just another guy whose size or charisma, moreso than any wrestling ability, has enabled him to get to the top in much the same way as Hogan or Warrior? Did being aligned with Flair, HHH and Orton allow him to 'hide' his technical shortcomings. Has his constant stream of injuries in recent years been an indicator that he should have stopped a long time ago. In short, is he just a doorman who struck lucky? And if he does announce his retirement on Monday, will anybody really miss him?