Experience has taught me that supplements are just that – a “supplement” to your diet.
Years ago I tried getting away 1 or 2 meals along with several shakes & bars throughout the day.
I made much better progress once I added whole eggs, milk, beef, and chicken to my regular diet.
Shakes are good to use on top of that, and they certainly have their place.
But I believe more & more that whole foods provide the necessary foundation from which to build.