jay vs phil: listening to the commentators on the webcast last night, the only thing that heath had over jay was his back detail! that's it! jay obviously outmasses him, kills him in the lower body (legs) department, is a better poser even during the prejudging, and jay is twice his size in width, heath is just too damn narrow.
add in the fact that cutler is the reigning mr.olympia and it's kind of like the boxing analogy when you have the champion against the contender. if the contender wants to win on the judge's card he has to KNOCK OUT THE CHAMPION! if it's close, the judges always always go with the champion, that is how it is in all "subjective" sports like boxing, ice skating, etcetera, when it's the opinion of judges on who the victor is.
right now, i see it 1)jay 2)heath 3)branch 4)dexter. will see what happens saturday night.