When Eddie deadlifted 500kg nobody came close. The best Thor managed was 440kg. I know Thor eventually lifted 501kg but Eddie was the first and he ranks above Thor in static strength. His upper body strength was more impressive than Thor. Look at him bench press here. Thor was not near that strong in the bench press.
Eddie also was the first to knock Thor down in their boxing match. He was also recovering from a torn biceps injury shortly prior to the match. Had he been uninjured and connected a few shots Thor would have been lights out.
"First" doesnt really mean much, its who did it last. Others are coming for that record.
I have no issue with his strength, he's a monster.
What's weak is his character. Also getting knocked down is also nothing, its how the fight ends.
He got his ass kicked.
Eddie was smart to get out early, as he was gassed beyond belief. Bleeding out his ears, heart almost exploding, ambulance trip after his deadlift.
Your reasoning doesnt work either about "had he connected" etc. He didnt. Like every boxing match.
Speculation doesnt count. Eddie had zero skills in there, he looked awkward.
He got his ass beat.
Im not attacking you obsidian, youre a good dude, I just dont think the "only if" stuff works (for anyone).
IF Eddies aunt had a penis, she'd be his uncle (etc)...