If Cutler had his size and shape with Coleman's crazy details, vascularity and striations, that would pretty much be an unbeatable combination. As it is Cutler deserves "mad props" for the dramatic improvements he's made in the past few years in his pursuit of the Big One.
I didn't used to be a fan but now I almost think it would be cool to see Jay win it. However, Ronnie's got the formula down every year and unless he really screws it up or comes in just looking torn to pieces (vis-a-vis the torn quad and reportedly torn tricep and left lat), the result is already a foregone conclusion.