Despite what your media tells you, only half of the Republican support base are religious nuts. The other half are people with libertarian leanings who believe limited government is essential to individual freedom. Why should we give 3/4 of our money to the government so they can "wisely spend it on our behalf" as though we were children or something? I prefer to keep taxes limited to only the necessary items, and decide for myself how my resources should be allocated.
...this is another weird thing Americans believe without question.
What's so bad about big government?
The model you support has lead America into the instability it's now suffering.
Small government does indeed mean more personal liberty for middle class Americans, but it also means:
-poor public school systems
-poor social welfare
-a homelessness rate to rival any third world country
-rampant crime
-most working class people living one paycheque away from destitution
-most middle class people living one diagnosis away from destitution
...but more importantly, it means a small government which cannot curb the Machiavellian machinations of big-money vested interests. So small government effectively means a Corporo-cracy.
As George Bernard Shaw so wisely said: "I don't want the working classes to have baths only for their sake, but also for my sake"
The Luke