Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure

Getbig Misc Discussion Boards => E-Board - Movies, Music, TV, Videogames, Comics => Topic started by: Parker on March 21, 2011, 08:57:57 AM

Title: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Parker on March 21, 2011, 08:57:57 AM
My question is, could Rogue drain The Hulk's power, and have it temporarily for herself? Like she can do with others, or is that "power beyond her capabilities" and would drive her crazy, due to the fact that it "Rage Power?
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: jprc10 on March 21, 2011, 09:02:26 AM
pm fatpanda or kiwiol.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BayGBM on March 21, 2011, 09:06:07 AM
Yes, Rogue could absorb Hulk's power, but it depends on which Hulk you are talking about.  In recent years, Marvel writers have given Hulk unlimited power (could not be injured, able to hold is breath underwater forever, even existing in the vacuum of space--which was a far cry from the Hulk in the first few decades of his existence.  Traditionally, hulk was very large and strong, but he was still made of flesh and bone.

There are limits to Rogue's power.  She could not absorb the full power of any of the Asgardian gods, nor could she absorb the full power of Juggernaut (granted by Cyttorak) though she was able to absorb a portion of that power.  Similarly, her personality does not always remain in control when she absorbs/merges with someone.  Sometimes the other person gains control of her body and her personality goes dormant for the duration of the transfer.

Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Parker on March 21, 2011, 09:37:04 AM
Yes, Rogue could absorb Hulk's power, but it depends on which Hulk you are talking about.  In recent years, Marvel writers have given Hulk unlimited power (could not be injured, able to hold is breath underwater forever, even existing in the vacuum of space--which was a far cry from the Hulk in the first few decades of his existence.  Traditionally, hulk was very large and strong, but he was still made of flesh and bone.

There are limits to Rogue's power.  She could not absorb the full power of any of the Asgardian gods, nor could she absorb the full power of Juggernaut (granted by Cyttorak) though she was able to absorb a portion of that power.  Similarly, her personality does not always remain in control when she absorbs/merges with someone.  Sometimes the other person gains control of her body and her personality goes dormant for the duration of the transfer.


Thanks, I was wondering...had a funny skit in my mind involving her, Hulk, and a jealous Gambit...
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Shockwave on March 21, 2011, 09:38:46 AM
Thanks, I was wondering...had a funny skit in my mind involving her, Hulk, and a jealous Gambit...
Lulz.
I can imagine where youre effed up mind is going.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: dr.chimps on March 21, 2011, 09:39:29 AM
pm fatpanda or kiwiol.
Careful what you ask for. kiwi would give a concise answer. FP would carry some silly argument for ten+ pages.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Parker on March 21, 2011, 09:50:03 AM
Lulz.
I can imagine where youre effed up mind is going.
Hahahhaha,
I was watching one of those X-men vids on YouTube where dudes were ad-libbing, and I thought it would be funny for sometone to have action figures...Rogue brings home Hulk as her new boyfriend, Gambit sees this and gets jealous, starts throwing cards. Hulk, starts laughing and says, "Hulk will keep it 100, Hulk will use all cards for strip poker tonight."

All of sudden He-Man is at the door (of The Xavier Institute), with his slightly sexually confused son (remember the He-Man cartoon from the early 2000s? Yep, that dude), well, seems that Storm has cooked up some sort of potion---cause you know, He-Man's is pissed, he broke off a dinner date to bring his son over.

Meanwhile, Clark Kent and Bruce Wayne are at the bar, they are talking about Lana Lang, "So, Clark, you and Lana didn't, you know, hook up?"
"Naaa, Bruce, she was one of those, take it slow types..."
"Yeah, Clark, I know the type, want to take it slow to not seem like a ho, but she's having her back blown out by the quarterback..."
"No, Bruce, she's not..."
"...Like that? Yeah, whatever, Imma keep it 100..."

And so, I thought about whether Rogue could absord Hulk's powers.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: dj181 on March 21, 2011, 09:56:41 AM
SILVER SURFER>everyone else
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: CalvinH on March 21, 2011, 10:00:41 AM
Careful what you ask for. kiwi would give a long winded, concise answer. FP would carry some silly argument for ten+ pages.



Fixed.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BIG ACH on March 21, 2011, 10:01:35 AM
Man the original X-MEN cartoon was fucking AWESOME!!!!!!

(http://www.scottking.info/Pics/MarvelXMenVolume5_Photo_03-566x411.jpg)
(http://chrisrrau.files.wordpress.com/2011/01/xmen.jpg)


The new one is pretty fucking lame..

(http://www.faithandgeekery.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/X-Men-Evolution-cast.jpg)
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: mesmorph78 on March 21, 2011, 10:05:02 AM
I think e has tried before... Didn't work ... I'll look into that further she tried to drain juggernaut didn't work drove her crazy ... There is a limit to the amount of energy she can absorb... And she could handles hulk rage
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: ToxicAvenger on March 21, 2011, 10:06:22 AM
My question is, could Rogue drain The Hulk's power, and have it temporarily for herself? Like she can do with others, or is that "power beyond her capabilities" and would drive her crazy, due to the fact that it "Rage Power?

what if i had explosive diarrhea and rogue touched me?
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BIG ACH on March 21, 2011, 10:19:27 AM

What if I was gay and she touched me?  Would she become a lesbian?  Would she get it on with Jean Grey?
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: MORTALCOIL on March 21, 2011, 10:21:33 AM
My question is, could Rogue Goodrum drain The Hulk's The Hammer's power cum, and have it temporarily for herself? Like she can do with others, or is that "power beyond her capabilities" and would drive her crazy, due to the fact that it "Rage Power?
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Rearden Metal on March 21, 2011, 10:28:33 AM
Since I'm gay what if she touched me?  Would she become a lesbian?  Would she get it on with Jean Grey?

FYP
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: basil on March 21, 2011, 11:06:51 AM
nerds.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: kiwiol on March 21, 2011, 11:07:04 AM
I haven't read any comics, but based on the movies, Rogue can only absorb the mutation powers of other mutants.

The Hulk is not a mutant.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Parker on March 21, 2011, 11:09:08 AM
what if i had explosive diarrhea and rogue touched me?
She may get Proteinfarts, but not Toxic Diarrhea...
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: ToxicAvenger on March 21, 2011, 11:18:51 AM
She may get Proteinfarts, but not Toxic Diarrhea...
;D


classic!

Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: kiwiol on March 21, 2011, 11:25:11 AM


Fixed.

Punkass Decepticon
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BIG ACH on March 21, 2011, 11:41:12 AM
I haven't read any comics, but based on the movies, Rogue can only absorb the mutation powers of other mutants.

The Hulk is not a mutant.


Just because The Hulk was not born a Mutant doesn't mean he's not a Mutant....

Most of Wolverine's powers are not from Birth (IE his Adamantium skeleton and claws) but she was still able to absorb his power!


Also, why did Rogue bitch so much about not having a boyfriend that could touch her, couldn't her bf have sex with her if he wore a condom since he wouldn't really be touching her?  I mean wtf!!!
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: MORTALCOIL on March 21, 2011, 11:56:15 AM
Just because The Hulk was not born a Mutant doesn't mean he's not a Mutant....

Most of Wolverine's powers are not from Birth (IE his Adamantium skeleton and claws) but she was still able to absorb his power!


Also, why did Rogue bitch so much about not having a boyfriend that could touch her, couldn't her bf have sex with her if he wore a condom since he wouldn't really be touching her?  I mean wtf!!!

Yep, that's a major flaw in an otherwise incredibly believable scenario.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: kiwiol on March 21, 2011, 11:58:37 AM
Just because The Hulk was not born a Mutant doesn't mean he's not a Mutant....

Most of Wolverine's powers are not from Birth (IE his Adamantium skeleton and claws) but she was still able to absorb his power!


Also, why did Rogue bitch so much about not having a boyfriend that could touch her, couldn't her bf have sex with her if he wore a condom since he wouldn't really be touching her?  I mean wtf!!!

Mutation is something you're born with and manifests itself when the mutant hits puberty.

The Hulk isn't a mutant - he had a unique accident as an adult, which caused him to change.

But anything goes in the Marvel universe, I suppose. Someone like Man of Steel or Fatpanda would know.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: ToxicAvenger on March 21, 2011, 02:21:39 PM

Also, why did Rogue bitch so much about not having a boyfriend that could touch her, couldn't her bf have sex with her if he wore a condom since he wouldn't really be touching her?  I mean wtf!!!

if she touched her boyfriend she'd grow a penis....  >:(
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Parker on March 21, 2011, 05:47:02 PM
Just because The Hulk was not born a Mutant doesn't mean he's not a Mutant....

Most of Wolverine's powers are not from Birth (IE his Adamantium skeleton and claws) but she was still able to absorb his power!


Also, why did Rogue bitch so much about not having a boyfriend that could touch her, couldn't her bf have sex with her if he wore a condom since he wouldn't really be touching her?  I mean wtf!!!
If you read Wolverine Origin, you'll see that he had the claws from a early age...

Also, Rogue had to wear gloves...so in order for her to have sex, she'd have to wear a full body condom...
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BayGBM on March 21, 2011, 06:27:53 PM
Mutation is something you're born with and manifests itself when the mutant hits puberty.

The Hulk isn't a mutant - he had a unique accident as an adult, which caused him to change.

But anything goes in the Marvel universe, I suppose. Someone like Man of Steel or Fatpanda would know.

This is true for genetic mutants like the X-Men or Franklin Richards, but mutations can be triggered by environmental factors.  I think the Hulk is an example of this.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: kiwiol on March 22, 2011, 09:55:13 AM
This is true for genetic mutants like the X-Men or Franklin Richards, but mutations can be triggered by environmental factors.  I think the Hulk is an example of this.

Alright then. I thought you had to be a real mutant, meaning be born with the genetic abnormality, for Rogue to be able to "borrow" your power.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BayGBM on March 23, 2011, 07:12:40 AM
Alright then. I thought you had to be a real mutant, meaning be born with the genetic abnormality, for Rogue to be able to "borrow" your power.

Why would you think that?  On many occasions Rogue has absorbed some or all of the power/abilities of people who are not genetic mutants.  Ms. Marvel for example.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BIG ACH on March 23, 2011, 11:38:21 AM
If you read Wolverine Origin, you'll see that he had the claws from a early age...

Also, Rogue had to wear gloves...so in order for her to have sex, she'd have to wear a full body condom...

Yes but his claws (and skeleton) were not Adamantium until they worked on him as Weapon X
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: kiwiol on March 23, 2011, 12:03:32 PM
Why would you think that?  On many occasions Rogue has absorbed some or all of the power/abilities of people who are not genetic mutants.  Ms. Marvel for example.

Because I've only seen a handful of episodes from the animated series and have read even less comics. I'm more of a DC guy than Marvel. So not familiar with stuff like what you've mentioned.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: tu_holmes on March 23, 2011, 12:11:23 PM
Rogue now has complete control of her powers and can touch anyone and not kill them or manifest their powers if she doesn't wish to do so.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BayGBM on March 23, 2011, 05:46:26 PM
Rogue now has complete control of her powers and can touch anyone and not kill them or manifest their powers if she doesn't wish to do so.

How did this come about?
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: tu_holmes on March 23, 2011, 09:51:30 PM
How did this come about?

Was an epiphany of sorts in one of the X books about 5 months back or so. I still read regularly.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: BayGBM on March 23, 2011, 10:04:36 PM
Was an epiphany of sorts in one of the X books about 5 months back or so. I still read regularly.

Doesn't really answer my question... but ok.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Parker on March 23, 2011, 10:33:23 PM
Yes but his claws (and skeleton) were not Adamantium until they worked on him as Weapon X
Yeah, but I think he also had the healing factor as well (checks comic books...)
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: DK II on March 24, 2011, 04:43:15 AM
I haven't read any comics, but based on the movies, Rogue can only absorb the mutation powers of other mutants.

The Hulk is not a mutant.



 :o :o :o

Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: tu_holmes on March 24, 2011, 11:58:02 AM
Doesn't really answer my question... but ok.

It was not some big thing... It was basically the white queen saying... You've always had the ability, you just don't do it... you're scared.

She stopped being scared, she controlled it... End of story.

It was more of a side item.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: Parker on March 24, 2011, 12:33:23 PM
It was not some big thing... It was basically the white queen saying... You've always had the ability, you just don't do it... you're scared.

She stopped being scared, she controlled it... End of story.

It was more of a side item.
I can't stand that white queen---always fuckig up the storyline...Returnt to Wonderland's Red Queen, now that is a sadistic, axe-weilding woman after my own heart
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: tu_holmes on March 24, 2011, 12:36:14 PM
Yeah, but I think he also had the healing factor as well (checks comic books...)

Yes... his claws and healing factor are his mutant ability... along with the enhanced senses of sight, hearing, and smell.

The adamantium could only be added to him BECAUSE he had that healing factor and wouldn't die from the injection process.
Title: Re: X-Men/Marvel Question
Post by: DK II on March 25, 2011, 01:12:25 AM
Yes... his claws and healing factor are his mutant ability... along with the enhanced senses of sight, hearing, and smell.

The adamantium could only be added to him BECAUSE he had that healing factor and wouldn't die from the injection process.

yes.