Well, Buff, not every guy fancies fit or even buff gals. That is the way some men are wired. If some perfer larger women then that is just what turns them on.
I can't speak for the ladies re the guys they fancy but most women find big muscles a turn off. Big, fat guys don't have that much luck with the ladies, either.
Poor Treb married the wrong woman and only found out too late. He still has time to hang out at CW saloons to find that long, lost fat babe.