Author Topic: Not meeting their anticipated potential? (Read 8108 times)

Scooby · « **on:** July 16, 2007, 12:44:42 PM »

With the discussion of all the Pro cards being given out over the past several years it brings up the question... What happens to all these girls after they turn Pro?

How many just fade away and never compete again? (Name some names if you know of any)

How many struggle in the Pro ranks trying to make Top 10 year after year? (Name some names if you know of any)

How many girls seemed to dominate NPC shows on their way to their Pro card and then just never live up to their anticipated potential as a Pro? (Name some names if you know of any)

Dina · « **Reply #1 on:** July 16, 2007, 02:22:56 PM »

ME.... hahahaha and my reason for not wanting to continue...

1. I dont want to take the drugs..and granted that not every person is on them.. I doubt the top are not on anything.. I have been there and know the dealio

2. I rather make real money than fritter it away on 2k suits and the hope of winning the O which would net 20k.. when I could make that in a month.

Scooby · « **Reply #2 on:** July 16, 2007, 02:50:23 PM »

Quote from: Dina on July 16, 2007, 02:22:56 PM

ME.... hahahaha and my reason for not wanting to continue...

No not you... you made a name for yourself in the pro ranks, you were a real threat to alot of girls.
I'm talking more girls like Jaime Franklin (poof gone), Casey Watts in fitness (poof gone), or Michelle Flake and Jeanette Freed who were always neck and neck at NPC shows then they get their Pro cards and after a few shows Flake vanishes and Freed although still around can't seem to get it together.

Quote from: Dina on July 16, 2007, 02:22:56 PM

20k.. when I could make that in a month.

Just let me know when you wanna earn that in a day and I'll bring my checkbook

Dina · « **Reply #3 on:** July 16, 2007, 03:34:52 PM »

Done.... send me your address... I will be there..lol better not be a rubber check..lol

In defense of some of these ladies, I think that life happens.. families... careers.. if only we could make decent money doing this... and now with so many ladies and an even better gene pool it gets harder and harder

Denny Crane · « **Reply #4 on:** July 16, 2007, 07:31:15 PM »

A beginning list of onstage disappointments:
Elaine Goodlad
Marcy Porter
Colette Flack
Michelle Flake
Ali McKnight
Jen Hartley
Melissa Frabbiele
Shelby Kadyk
Amy Peters
Heather Mae French
Corry Matthews
Liane Seiwald
Alexis Ellis
Zena Collins
Laura Sutter
Lisa Schaerer-Maloy
Stephanie Collins
Elizabeth Lamm

Solid Attitude · « **Reply #5 on:** July 16, 2007, 08:14:04 PM »

Quote from: Denny Crane on July 16, 2007, 07:31:15 PM

A beginning list of onstage disappointments:
Elaine Goodlad
Marcy Porter
Colette Flack
Michelle Flake
Ali McKnight
Jen Hartley
Melissa Frabbiele
Shelby Kadyk
Amy Peters
Heather Mae French
Corry Matthews
Liane Seiwald
Alexis Ellis
Zena Collins
Laura Sutter
Lisa Schaerer-Maloy
Stephanie Collins
Elizabeth Lamm

Wow! This is the disappointing list!
First off there are girls on here who have only been on stage once or twice and their a disappointment?
Secondly, I will say this Stephanie Collins is the one of the most pleasant people in the sport. She seems to never get upset about her placing and looks to have more fun than just about anybody on stage. You know maybe Steph has really figured it out and we all could learn something.

And Lastly, I'm sorry but Elaine Goodlad?

Disappointment ain't never looked so GOOD!!!!!!!

Denny Crane · « **Reply #6 on:** July 16, 2007, 08:44:43 PM »

Quote from: Solid Attitude on July 16, 2007, 08:14:04 PM

Wow! This is the disappointing list!
First off there are girls on here who have only been on stage once or twice and their a disappointment?
Secondly, I will say this Stephanie Collins is the one of the most pleasant people in the sport. She seems to never get upset about her placing and looks to have more fun than just about anybody on stage. You know maybe Steph has really figured it out and we all could learn something.

And Lastly, I'm sorry but Elaine Goodlad?
Disappointment ain't never looked so GOOD!!!!!!!

It's not a personality contest, chief. Maybe she has reached her potential. Who besides Stephanie has only been on stage once?

Elaine Goodlad looks good in the magazines but on stage she never matched what she's done off the stage. That was the question, How many struggle in the Pro ranks trying to make Top 10 year after year?

Add Milmar Sarcev to the list.

Solid Attitude · « **Reply #7 on:** July 16, 2007, 09:00:08 PM »

Well DC, we can tell you are not real familar w/ these girls at all.
Steph has been on stage a number of times. My point was that it comes down to what you think disappointing means. To me Steph is a bright spot in the sport and far from a disapointment.
Who on your list how bout Cory Mathews? Give the girl some time she will do just fine. Elizabeth Lamm had some quality callouts her rookie year, not having a great 2007, but she will be the first to tell you she's still trying to figure out some things and she to will place wll soon.
As far as Elaine Goodlad goes you say she has never matched what she has done off the stage AHHHHH what the heck does that mean. What were your expectations of Elaine? Did you follow her through the amateur ranks? No what you are basically saying is she is drop dead gorgeous as a model and has not been able to duplicate that on stage, which one has entirley nothing to do w/ the other.
All I am saying is they all made it to where they are now, not everybody can place top five at every show, but they are all far from disappointing.

Denny Crane · « **Reply #8 on:** July 16, 2007, 09:18:36 PM »

Quote from: Solid Attitude on July 16, 2007, 09:00:08 PM

Well DC, we can tell you are not real familar w/ these girls at all.
Steph has been on stage a number of times. My point was that it comes down to what you think disappointing means. To me Steph is a bright spot in the sport and far from a disapointment.
Who on your list how bout Cory Mathews? Give the girl some time she will do just fine. Elizabeth Lamm had some quality callouts her rookie year, not having a great 2007, but she will be the first to tell you she's still trying to figure out some things and she to will place wll soon.
As far as Elaine Goodlad goes you say she has never matched what she has done off the stage AHHHHH what the heck does that mean. What were your expectations of Elaine? Did you follow her through the amateur ranks? No what you are basically saying is she is drop dead gorgeous as a model and has not been able to duplicate that on stage, which one has entirley nothing to do w/ the other.
All I am saying is they all made it to where they are now, not everybody can place top five at every show, but they are all far from disappointing.

You're not the sharpest tool in your shed are you? What happens to all these girls after they turn Pro? How many times has Steph been on stage as a pro? I'm sure she's nice, never met her but she is everything wrong with figure when you see her contest photos and in her two piece. Corry Matthews has been on stage a few times if I am not mistaken and as soft as a hostess twinkie. Exactly what I am saying about Elaine. She is a super model off stage and done far more there then on stage. What's her highest placings? Compared to her off stage accomplishments. DISAPPOINTMENT. Not everyone has the right connections is what you're saying?

Tivo me, will ya?

Fit Gourmet · « **Reply #9 on:** July 16, 2007, 10:14:09 PM »

Alexis Ellis is in School. She will return when Done. Alexis Competes to promote her business. She has only done two shows, and will do more!! if the small amount of Publicity helps her in some way. The Prize money is no incentive.

Scooby · « **Reply #10 on:** July 17, 2007, 06:49:05 AM »

I admit Denny's list is pretty good...
I personally would remove Corry Matthews & Stephanie Collins because they are just to new to be disappointing yet. It wasn't like they lit the NPC on fire on their way up, so they still need a chance to develop as a Pro.

Elaine Goodlad? That's just crazy putting her on the list... she was consistent Top 5 and higher for several years which is a damn good record... The main reason not to be on the list she WON the California Pro show in 2004.

I forgot about Ali McKnight and Jen Hartley... definitely they make the list.

Zena is a good one for the list since her placings just seem to keep sliding down.

Amy Peters, ok, extremely inconsistent placings, in that category I would also add Christine Wan.

Good list so far Denny... any more?

Scooby · « **Reply #11 on:** July 17, 2007, 07:33:00 AM »

Quote from: Solid Attitude on July 16, 2007, 08:14:04 PM

And Lastly, I'm sorry but Elaine Goodlad?
Disappointment ain't never looked so GOOD!!!!!!!

Hey... You are married, act like it!!! Keep your perverted fantasies off this thread and put them in Dina's porno thread where they belong!

Christine Wan · « **Reply #12 on:** July 17, 2007, 07:46:39 AM »

Quote from: Scooby on June 25, 2007, 11:58:29 AM

I've always been a huge fan of Christine Wan too, she has a dynamite physique... and I think she is often overlooked for some reason.

Hi Scooby.

I do agree with you, that I have not brought my potential best to the stage. Perhaps I came close last year when I was top five - twice. However, I've been busy being a full-time mother to a baby-turned-toddler. My priorities and focus have been elsewhere. My daughter is now just four and a half. I turned pro in 2003. Do the math.

As for Elaine...has everyone forgotten that she WON the California Pro in 2004? Only once, I think, did she place outside of the top ten. And that she is 43 YEARS OLD? If it seems like she is not competing up to her potential, then I would say it is by choice. Perhaps competing against women half her age and being judged onstage, in a bikini, by a panel of strangers, is not as appealing as it used to be when she was, say, in her late 30's (like me).

Scooby · « **Reply #13 on:** July 17, 2007, 07:49:45 AM »

Quote from: Christine Wan on July 17, 2007, 07:46:39 AM

Hi Scooby.

I do agree with you,

Glad you agree

JustaFan · « **Reply #14 on:** July 17, 2007, 09:40:43 AM »

Zena Collins never had potential. She had a few good finishes a couple years ago because she signed with that guy who dresses up like comic book characters..

Jen Searles went from like 15th place to top 5 the next show after she signed with him as well.

Elaine had a pretty good career. Extremely pretty.

Tara Scotti always placed high, but she has been training at Bev and Steve's for a long time.

Christine Wan can look good sometimes, but very inconsistent. Looks good 1 show, and terrible the next.

Our resident Dina Al Sabah was a threat back when Figure first started and there were only like 10 girls competing, but once she tried to get on stage with more competition, she was not even top 10 material in small shows. In her defense, she is 1 of the prettier girls on stage, and because she has a heavy internet presence, she is very popular. From what I heard from other people on this board, she is not as sociable in person as she seems in the online world. I guess none of are though.

Shannon M, ( can't spell her name ) her placings always seemed to baffle me.

I will report on more girls later....

Lift Studios · « **Reply #15 on:** July 17, 2007, 10:29:38 AM »

Quote from: JustaFan on July 17, 2007, 09:40:43 AM

Zena Collins never had potential. She had a few good finishes a couple years ago because she signed with that guy who dresses up like comic book characters..

Jen Searles went from like 15th place to top 5 the next show after she signed with him as well.

Elaine had a pretty good career. Extremely pretty.

Tara Scotti always placed high, but she has been training at Bev and Steve's for a long time.

Christine Wan can look good sometimes, but very inconsistent. Looks good 1 show, and terrible the next.

Our resident Dina Al Sabah was a threat back when Figure first started and there were only like 10 girls competing, but once she tried to get on stage with more competition, she was not even top 10 material in small shows. In her defense, she is 1 of the prettier girls on stage, and because she has a heavy internet presence, she is very popular. From what I heard from other people on this board, she is not as sociable in person as she seems in the online world. I guess none of are though.

Shannon M, ( can't spell her name ) her placings always seemed to baffle me.

I will report on more girls later....

It's amusing how people find faults in those who place well. Tara is a no BS kinda girl and her placings were deserved.

Dina is sociable and anyone who isn't a social misfit would be able to have a conversation with her. Most people are much friendly in person than on the boards. If you didn't approach them with your photos of them from their last show in your 99 cent binder you might get a better response.

I'd say there are far more fitness pros that fail to reach their potential or are a disappointment in the pro ranks. There really hasn't been anyone who came out of the am. ranks and shook things up in the pros. Your top 5 contenders have been the same for a few years now.

TheGrinch · « **Reply #16 on:** July 17, 2007, 10:50:28 AM »

Quote from: Dina on July 16, 2007, 02:22:56 PM

ME.... hahahaha and my reason for not wanting to continue...

1. I dont want to take the drugs..and granted that not every person is on them.. I doubt the top are not on anything.. I have been there and know the dealio

2. I rather make real money than fritter it away on 2k suits and the hope of winning the O which would net 20k.. when I could make that in a month.

Please let me know where I can also make 20k per month

JustaFan · « **Reply #17 on:** July 17, 2007, 11:33:31 AM »

Quote

It's amusing how people find faults in those who place well. Tara is a no BS kinda girl and her placings were deserved.

Your right. I just like to give my opinions. And to play Devil's Advocate, I have never seen pictures of Tara on stage and out of shape. She is always in great shape. I just would have felt better about her placings if she didn't have any connection to the NPC/IFBB mafia. At least she didnt sign with "that weird guy"

Quote

If you didn't approach them with your photos of them from their last show in your 99 cent binder you might get a better response.

Isaac, don't sell me short. I buy the expensive trapper keepers to keep my photos in. And by the way, I banged more fitness pro's and bodybuilder chicks ( Before the Figure Days ) then you have designed websites..... But its all good. I still enjoy your rants on these forums........

Lift Studios · « **Reply #18 on:** July 17, 2007, 12:05:47 PM »

Quote from: JustaFan on July 17, 2007, 11:33:31 AM

Your right. I just like to give my opinions. And to play Devil's Advocate, I have never seen pictures of Tara on stage and out of shape. She is always in great shape. I just would have felt better about her placings if she didn't have any connection to the NPC/IFBB mafia. At least she didnt sign with "that weird guy"

Isaac, don't sell me short. I buy the expensive trapper keepers to keep my photos in. And by the way, I banged more fitness pro's and bodybuilder chicks ( Before the Figure Days ) then you have designed websites..... But its all good. I still enjoy your rants on these forums........

What is they say about opinions.

Nice mid-80s reference wiht the trapper keeper. LMAO!

Congrats on your banging, I'm sure your mom would be proud.

JustaFan · « **Reply #19 on:** July 17, 2007, 12:18:18 PM »

Quote from: Lift Studios on July 17, 2007, 12:05:47 PM

What is they say about opinions.

Nice mid-80s reference wiht the trapper keeper. LMAO!

Congrats on your banging, I'm sure your mom would be proud.

My mom would actually be repulsed by the things I have done with these fitness girls, but I sure am proud.

I will buy you a drink at the Olympia and I will tell you some stories.....

Dina · « **Reply #20 on:** July 17, 2007, 01:28:43 PM »

I see this thread has degenerated into bangings and sexual exploits... get back on track boys! that goes for you too Denny

Denny Crane · « **Reply #21 on:** July 17, 2007, 02:47:25 PM »

Quote from: Fit Gourmet on July 16, 2007, 10:14:09 PM

Alexis Ellis is in School. She will return when Done. Alexis Competes to promote her business. She has only done two shows, and will do more!! if the small amount of Publicity helps her in some way. The Prize money is no incentive.

Tied for 16th and that's not good publicity.

More for your list
Alana Hernandez
Jennifer Becerra
Zhanna Rotar
Tammy Pies
Pauline Nordin
Karen Zaremba
Rebecca Rush
Sherie Salvadori
Shelley Taucher
Aleksandra Kobielak
Bridget Murray
Allison Daughtry
Sandra Wickham
Sandie Ward
Kristina Henn
Trish Mayberry
Madonna Grimes
Bethany Howlett
Jennifer Hanke
Karen Walcott
Brittany Thorsch

Scooby · « **Reply #22 on:** July 17, 2007, 03:04:09 PM »

Quote from: Denny Crane on July 17, 2007, 02:47:25 PM

More for your list
Alana Hernandez
Jennifer Becerra
Zhanna Rotar
Tammy Pies
Pauline Nordin
Karen Zaremba
Rebecca Rush
Sherie Salvadori
Shelley Taucher
Aleksandra Kobielak
Bridget Murray
Allison Daughtry
Sandra Wickham
Sandie Ward
Kristina Henn
Trish Mayberry
Madonna Grimes
Bethany Howlett
Jennifer Hanke
Karen Walcott
Brittany Thorsch

Damn Denny... I'm impressed, you are coming up with names that I had totally forgotten about.
- Zhanna Rotar might be a little too new and really unproven to include just yet.
- Jennifer Hanke was consistent top 5 in smaller shows (maybe a win) and has since retired

Dina · « **Reply #23 on:** July 17, 2007, 10:18:43 PM »

Aleksandra did well in Europe.... and made it to the O. I think anyone making to the O more than once has done well... JMHO

Tre · « **Reply #24 on:** July 17, 2007, 11:37:06 PM »

Quote from: Denny Crane on July 16, 2007, 07:31:15 PM

A beginning list of onstage disappointments:
Elaine Goodlad
Marcy Porter
Colette Flack
Michelle Flake
Ali McKnight
Jen Hartley
Melissa Frabbiele
Shelby Kadyk
Amy Peters
Heather Mae French
Corry Matthews
Liane Seiwald
Alexis Ellis
Zena Collins
Laura Sutter
Lisa Schaerer-Maloy
Stephanie Collins
Elizabeth Lamm

If that's your 'disappointment list', then I'd say the sport - and the industry as a whole - is in GREAT shape!