Many, many good points passed in this thread.
For one, yes JC's contest coverage is outstanding. Hardfitness.com is saved in my favorites, and I am always on that site. The coverage is up quick, I love the way it's sorted by competitor name etc...and in my opinion is the best contest coverage for females available online.
The cover shots though do blow, and it's not occasionally, it's all the time. I know nothing of photography, but I have literally seen better pics posted here by girls who just had their husband/friend casually take a pic. My non-photographer self wonders why the contest pics are so good, and the 'covers' are not. I think what Jodi mentioned about using a contest pic as a 'cover' seems a good idea. I have seen zillions of hardfitness contest pics posted here, posted at least 50 myself and don't ever recall the quality being slammed, but the 'cover' pic gets slammed month after month...even by the non-trolls.