his torso completly dwarfs everything else
his arms look long and way too small for his body
non-existant legs
Compare him to a guy like Lee Labrada and I think Lee looks much better
You're using modern criteria to judge a guy from a totally different era. Yes, his arms were reasonably small - so were Dorian's compared to his torso. Hell, people have even claimed the same with Ronnie Coleman some years. When you have a huge back you do often get the 'small arms' complaint.
The legs issue is not relevant here as in those days judging was still much closer to that of the golden age; Arnold did not have huge legs. In fact, hardly any of them did until the era of the freak ( Tom Platz excepted). Labrada looked great, another pleasing physique before the GH monsters, and he was regularly top 4 but he still couldn't beat Haney. Haney was far and away the best of his era.