I had Johnny Stewart winning it on muscle, or Rusty on lines.
I guess the judges went with the guy who was 2nd in both of those categories, which does happen.
I think many people believed the show was fixed because it was one of the early webcasts, and the BBing.com camera followed Bob the entire time - offstage, during the posedown, etc, it was like the Bob Chic show. Really laughable... Bob would start to move during the posedown, it would follow him. He'd come back, it would follow him again the other way. All the while you had Pavol and Stewart comparing most musculars - a great comparison - and all we saw was bob wiping his nose looking for which way to walk.
Of course they wanted to highlight their athlete, but at the same time it did create that perception.