Dorian Yates at his best VS Ronnie Coleman at his best : who would win?

[NarcissisticDeity]

1994 at one of his worse showings mind you , this front latspread is just mindblowing

[JasonH]

Lets break it down into bodyparts

Chest = Ronnie
Biceps = Ronnie
Triceps = Dorian
Delts = Ronnie
Quads = Ronnie
Hams and glute tie-ins = close, but I'd give it to Dorian
Back = Ronnie
Calves = Dorian
Abs = Dorian

Ronnie wins, but barely.

[England_1]

Sorry, but Ronnie's back was no where near as thick as Yates.

[Earl1972]

1994 at one of his worse showings mind you , this front latspread is just mindblowing

look son you have to judge the whole body, not just the lats

shallow chest, small arms, ugly waistline, calves too big for his quads, lack of cuts in quads

E

[Emmortal]

Gotta disagree about giving Hams to Dorian:

[NarcissisticDeity]

look son you have to judge the whole body, not just the lats

shallow chest, small arms, ugly waistline, calves too big for his quads, lack of cuts in quads

E

funny you typed the word judge   because according to the judges he soundly defeated everyone in this and all the other poses , so despite your claims he was still dominant

[Earl1972]

funny you typed the word judge   because according to the judges he soundly defeated everyone in this and all the other poses , so despite your claims he was still dominant

you only agree with the judging when dorian wins

E

[NarcissisticDeity]

you only agree with the judging when dorian wins

E

Earl you're constantly and incorrectly prone for speaking for me and when you do its an outright lie , you really should pay more attention , I have said several times I don't think Dorian should have won in 1997 , I'm a huge Flex Wheeler fan and I agreed he should have lost in 98/99 , I didn't think Ronnie should have won in 2001 but I in no way shape of form think the contest was fixed , so Earl stop committing to posts that make you looks ignorant

[Earl1972]

Earl you're constantly and incorrectly prone for speaking for me and when you do its an outright lie , you really should pay more attention , I have said several times I don't think Dorian should have won in 1997 , I'm a huge Flex Wheeler fan and I agreed he should have lost in 98/99 , I didn't think Ronnie should have won in 2001 but I in no way shape of form think the contest was fixed , so Earl stop committing to posts that make you looks ignorant

didn't dorian win with perfect scores in 97?

E

[NarcissisticDeity]

didn't dorian win with perfect scores in 97?

E

yup

[Earl1972]

yup

so why did you say before that the judges scored him perfectly when i pointed out dorian's flaws

it was like you were saying the judges always get it right

E

[Hulkster]

ND doesn't care about all dorian's flaws.

he only cares about what score the judges gave him

thats what makes him such an ignorant fan:

he blindly goes by the numbers on the page rather than the physique on stage...

which is a big difference when you compare dorian's flaws (esp. his post tear fiasco's) to his actual scores..

torn crippled bi yet perfect scores? LOL

 

[Hulkster]

so why did you say before that the judges scored him perfectly when i pointed out dorian's flaws

it was like you were saying the judges always get it right

E

ND always thinks the judges are 100% correct all the time.

 

[Hulkster]

1994 at one of his worse showings mind you , this front latspread is just mindblowing

his lats are great and thick

but look at everything else:

poor quad cuts

zero chest cuts

no arm/delt cuts.

compared to a real lat spread, its pitiful:

[NarcissisticDeity]

so why did you say before that the judges scored him perfectly when i pointed out dorian's flaws

it was like you were saying the judges always get it right

E

What part of I don't think Dorian should have won in 1997 did you miss? let me know?

[NarcissisticDeity]

ND doesn't care about all dorian's flaws.

he only cares about what score the judges gave him

thats what makes him such an ignorant fan:

he blindly goes by the numbers on the page rather than the physique on stage...

which is a big difference when you compare dorian's flaws (esp. his post tear fiasco's) to his actual scores..

torn crippled bi yet perfect scores? LOL

 

lol no calves and yet a perfect score? LOL Hulkster I judge the physique's I seen which is how I came to the conclusion Dorian has better balance , which I verified after the fact via an IFBB judge , the subject of conditioning is trick to ascertain via pics & vids but I've again confirmed after the fact Yates has the better conditioning of the two via an IFBB judge , you see what you want in pictures bias prevents you from seeing things objectively

[NarcissisticDeity]

his lats are great and thick

but look at everything else:

poor quad cuts

zero chest cuts

no arm/delt cuts.

compared to a real lat spread, its pitiful:

one can just laugh at your assessment Yates' latspread is unmatched even to this day although thats among the best front latspread I've seen from Ronnie , he looks great in that shot , reminds me of Haney

[Hulkster]

one can just laugh at your assessment Yates' latspread is unmatched even to this day although thats among the best front latspread I've seen from Ronnie , he looks great in that shot , reminds me of Haney

and Haney beat Yates...

[NarcissisticDeity]

and Haney beat Yates...

And Yates beat Haney .......in the muscularity round , despite being 10 pounds lighter 

[Hulkster]

And Yates beat Haney .......in the muscularity round , despite being 10 pounds lighter 

Haney won the contest.

he was like Ronnie - mass with symmetry and aesthetics aka mass with class.

unlike dorian - mass with ass..

 

[Hulkster]

even dorian's famous lat spread cannot stand up to the standard that Ronnie Coleman 1999 set:

no matter what year

[Hulkster]

ouch.

look at the ownage in the quads, the pecs, the arms..

lats are equal.

dorian wins calves (as always, thats about it LOL)

[NarcissisticDeity]

even dorian's famous lat spread cannot stand up to the standard that Ronnie Coleman 1999 set:

no matter what year

lol end of story , Ronnie's front latspread that year great , Dorian's textbook flawless

[NarcissisticDeity]

Haney won the contest.

he was like Ronnie - mass with symmetry and aesthetics aka mass with class.

unlike dorian - mass with ass..

 

I always laugh when you type aesthetics , where was he on that list again?

[NarcissisticDeity]