Honestly, I don't know much about bodybuilding and that judging stuff. But I haven't seen one picture in my mind where Cutler looks better than Ruhl. Ruhl is way bigger, both of them are smooth and blocky.
The one is a 2 time Mr. Olympia and multiple times Arnold Classics champ, the other was lucky to crack the Top 10 at the Olympia and a final at other shows most of the time.
So what exactly is better about Jays body that he always placed tremedously higher than Ruhl?
