I'm impressed that you're a fan of the Ramon Allones Specially Selected. I had a San Cristobal and VSG illusion last night. Gave my friends Bolivar Belicosos.
I'll be having a cigar this afternoon.
Haha, great name!  I hadn't heard of that before.
I usually just select based on the brands that I've enjoyed before and the smoking time.  I usually steer clear of monsters, mostly because of cost but also because 30 minutes is enough for me.  The staff at 
 Devlins  is pretty knowledgeable so I usually ask them to recommend something I haven't tried before when I go in.  
It's the best shop in town by far for selection and advice but it suffers badly from the snootiness that sometimes afflicts the Cigar World.  I think I hurt the dude's feelings in there one day when I laughed at the prices on their lighters.  Who needs a $1000 lighter ffs.  "No, I've got a Bic, I'm good thanks."