Both years were kind of similar.
In 2001, NOBODY thought that Jay could nearly win Mr Olympia....nobody. Jay was 8th in 2000, and then dominated the field in 2001 (well he didnt dominate Coleman but Jay won the prejudging) and beat very big names.
In 2009....nobody expected Jay would look they way he did....huge, ripped and with a much smaller waist than previous years. His arm and leg imbalances seemed corrected too (not perfect but very good)