Then that has to be the weirdest and strangest criteria I've ever heard about. 
I honestly see Ronnie beating Dorian, whether you use Ronnie 98 or 99 with Dorian 93 or 95.
You don't know the criteria so how can you determine if it's strange or not?
Ronnie 1998 beat Flex by the skin of his teeth , the contest was separated by just 3 points one of the closest in the contest's history. Dorian 1993 blew Flex Wheeler out of the water and Flex looked eons better in 93 than he did in 98 , Ronnie 1998 couldn't beat Dorian not by a long shot
Ronnie 99 a little bigger & softer not as dry , Dorian would beat him this year too , Dorian would be harder & drier while being 260lbs with better balance & proportion & posing this is contest Dorian