Can you read? Dex has always been one of the smallest guys, the only time this guy can score is when he comes in SUPER-SHREDDED, what he did for years. When his conditioning is off only by 3 %, what has been the case the last couple of shows, that guy has no business being in the Top 5.
Can you read, Dex's conditioning was better than Branch's at the 2009 O, and had a better back. Yes his conditioning has faltered, but not by that much...
The people who are beating him, like Branch who is about the same height, are larger, yet have ugly unsymmetrical physiques...they also judge or punish guys for not coming in like their previous best. There is a punishment/reward type of mentality in the judging.
And as you look at the physiques, they are getting worse and worse...no more crispness, but more plastic looking...the judges are rewardig these looks...
Dex, either needs to retire, or reassess the situation and come in his razor sharp self again, so them what the standard was/is. That was his calling card....and if others come in less than that, he picks them apart.