you had more fun with those older games because you were younger and more easily amused and impressed
if you played most of those games for the first time today you probably wouldn't enjoy them as much
my favorite game of all time is resident evil but i'll be the first to admit it is very dated at this point
E
That's odd... Considering how my 11 year old son who is just recently playing games like Zelda and Super Mario Bros. 2 and 3 is absolutely in love with them.
Double Dragon is also one of his favorites... So I will disagree that it's my "nostalgia".
Since when does the "look" of a game and how it's "dated" mean that it's not fun?
If we are talking NES/SMS-era I'm a bit torn. The "classics" from those systems are classics for a reason, no doubt. But a TON of the software that was released was pretty bad.
Also, game design back then was hampered by tech limitations. A lot of games (platformers/shooters especially) were filled with cheapness, grinding etc. to extend play-times and such.
Bad developers used that crap to extend their game and make it more "challenging," good developers would be able to craft a game within the tech limitations that was challenging but not rage quit frustrating.
Bad games are universal... When the game sucks, no one cares what year it was... The reality was just that it was not fun to play.
Fun factor is the ultimate test of a game.
I think the point is, even though dated, there have been few games that matched scenes like the Dog Scene in the original RE. The whole mood, game play (even though a bit clunky) and overall experience of games like RE were amazing.
And, to be honest, I'm not on either side of this. I've liked many games from each generation.
I've liked many games from each gen also... One of my top 5 games of all time was on the Dreamcast for goodness' sake!
As I said above... Fun is what it's about. Just because it looks good doesn't mean shit to me. If it's fun, it's fun. Looks be damned.
Fuck, Tetris hasn't changed much in the past 30 years, but it's still one of the most fun games to play.