Dorian Yates vs. Jay Cutler - At their best, who wins?

[RocketSwitch625]

ND.... show a picture where Dorian looks more dominant or dare I say thicker lmao

[NarcissisticDeity]

No ND, you come out here acting like you are captain Jim Manion, head of the IFBB. Please man, you are a peon who has no experience judging BB shows. Your opinion is that. You are really good at google and have downloaded a million pics of your savior Dorian, but dude come on. Your obsession is fanatical. You are a New England Patriots fan who continues to revel in SB victories in 2003 and 2004. Please man, come off of it. DY was great. Nobody claims differently. However, your continuing assertion that he is the best of all-time is absurd. You always state he beat Ronnie. Ronnie was a boy when he faced Dorian. Ronnie in his later years would have smoked Dorian. Using your own logic, Haney beat Dorian so he was better. Yet you claim he retired because he was scared of Yates. First, Haney would have beaten Yates in 1992 for number 9. Second, Yates decided to go on the mega juice in 1993 to come in 10-15 pounds heavier. Obviously, his build was chemically dependent just looking at recent pics of him. He was an A+ anabolic, GH, and insulin responder and was more disciplined than his competition. Can you honestly say that if say Dennis Newman never got ill with leukemia, maintained his lines, and took the shit Dorian took he would not be in the discussion for best of all-time. DY was average genetically with mutant parts. He did not flow like others. Deal with it. Great but not the best by any stretch of the imagination.

meltdown 2

 

continue with your emotional tirade

[Hulkster]

ND.... show a picture where Dorian looks more dominant or dare I say thicker lmao

dorian just gets crushed time after time from a post mr. o ronnie

dorian could only beat ronnie when he was losing to guys like porter cottrel.

this is a point the nuthuggers like ND don't seem to get..

[Hulkster]

interesting to note in the above comparions dorian outweighs ronnie by about 10 pounds (ronnie trimmed down for his AC win)

yet because of the amazing shape, detail and vascularity (completely absent in dorian's pose) Ronnie looks bigger.

ronnie had quality. that of a champion bodybuilder.

dorian had a construction worker's physique

[Hulkster]

seriously?

[ESFitness]

Same excuses as usual. no substance. What happened on stage? On stage is what counts. Haney 2, Yates 0.

Haney 8 Mr. Os
Yates 6 Mr. Os

End of story Haney is better...No what if bullshit.

put haney in a lineup from '95 on and he wouldn't make top 5.

[NarcissisticDeity]

dorian just gets crushed time after time from a post mr. o ronnie

dorian could only beat ronnie when he was losing to guys like porter cottrel.

this is a point the nuthuggers like ND don't seem to get..

Put Ronnie 2001 next to Dorian 1993 and he would look PETITE 

[NarcissisticDeity]

put haney in a lineup from '95 on and he wouldn't make top 5.

Great point ! The sport passed Haney by NOT his fault he went out ontop and good for him

[NarcissisticDeity]

seriously?

Wow the old Ronnie wins 1 pose comparison so he will win the entire contest    nice WORKED pic of Ronnie too  

Dorian kills Ronnie in the mandatories  Keep your MM pose and the standing relaxed from the front because Ronnie gets OBLITERATED in all others

[Grape Ape]

interesting to note in the above comparions dorian outweighs ronnie by about 10 pounds (ronnie trimmed down for his AC win)

interesting to note the guy who has never been to a competition and has no context of what an onstage pro bodybuilder looks like is still comparing two stand alone pics and thinking he can draw absolute conclusions.

[oldschoolfan]

hulkster have you ever been inside the ronnie bus

[Shockwave]

interesting to note the guy who has never been to a competition and has no context of what an onstage pro bodybuilder looks like is still comparing two stand alone pics and thinking he can draw absolute conclusions.

heh.
pics from different angles at that. Not the sharpest tool in the shed

[NarcissisticDeity]

heh.
pics from different angles at that. Not the sharpest tool in the shed

He never was

[Wiggs]

You assholes!  What happened to my thread?  Jay, Dorian?  I feel like I'm back in 2006 in this thread.

[NarcissisticDeity]

You assholes!  What happened to my thread?  Jay, Dorian?  I feel like I'm back in 2006 in this thread.

You know what happened , same old news Ronnie fan boys 

[Shockwave]

You assholes!  What happened to my thread?  Jay, Dorian?  I feel like I'm back in 2006 in this thread.

Jay lost, people moved on.

Jay couldnt carry Dorians jockstrap. Hell, I doubt Kay could hold the Cheaths jockstrap.