logical fallacy. you do not know the experiences of every atheist.
Tell that to the many atheists who were raised in strict religious homes. Matt Dillahunty from the Atheist Experience was studying to be a pastor for over 20 years.
dont make generalizations about atheists, because trust me, there are many generalizations about theists.
No logical fallacy because I purposefully said "uninformed, inexperienced opinions of similar atheists".........those similiar to Erik....not all atheists.
I've watched Matt Dillahunty and crew for years and he's admitted he never fully believed. He also did not study to be a pastor for 20 years. He was raised in a home of believers for about 20 years and during the end of that time he briefly pursued the seminary, but he couldn't get past his disbelief (I'm paraphrasing here).
Certainly Matt participated actively in church activities for all of his youth and I belief he gave it his all....I truly do. The difference I see is that he never surrendered to God and he never experienced the Holy Spirit. He's stated that he attended church events in which others around him experienced the presence of God and that he would close his eyes and try, but didn't.....again that nagging disbelief held him back and hence he could not discern the things of God.
Matt is a bit of an anomaly in the atheist circle, but certainly not irreconcilable in terms of theism. His works and disbelief certainly vet his supposed faith.