You guys might find it much better to focus on one goal at a time. If you're trying to get bigger and stronger focus on that by eating above maintance for a while. You'll end up gaining a little fat but you can always diet that off. Even if you don't compete I would advise training in this manner.....gain, cut,gain,cut.
This speeds up gains for me and it makes the whole process a lot more interesting by seeing my body going through constant changes. It keeps me motivated. If I didn't do this I probably would have quit long ago.