I'm no authority on this, but just about every girlfriend I have tells me that when it comes to a man's physical appearance they prefer men that carry low body fat levels around 10%, have flat abdomens (ideally abs), bodyweight under 200lbs and a chiseled face.
Also, what I can tell you is that no woman I've ever befriended or known through others has EVER said they find IFBB pros attractive. They're usually disgusted by their size and often wonder whether they have very small cocks.
I think most women today like men that look stylish in regular clothing and suits, but when the clothes come off sport a pretty shredded body.
What I will agree with ArmyOfOne on is that the massive size to most amateur or pro bodybuilders is ONLY impressive to other men. Women just don't get moved by that, because frankly, it's not sexy. And for those that will throw the Rock into the mix and suggest that he is huge and women love him, I'd say that's true, but they love him for his charm, charisma, attractive looking face, height and above all else FAME and MONEY.
"1"