Dorian Yates kicks Ronnie's ass Hulkster is a punk Bitch and fuck any truce

[D_1000]

The only person that I can think of that comes close to Platz is Branch Warren.

No. For that, Branch's quads would have to be more than just blobs of muscle.

[pumpster]

No. For that, Branch's quads would have to be more than just blobs of muscle.

LOL absolutely no comparison. DeMayo yes, Warren fuggedaboudit.

[The_Iron_Disciple]

I certainly don't mean ANY disrespect guys, but you all must've thought I was Born yesterday ... I wouldn't post something if I don't know what I was talking about ! Tell me, does this picture just show " blobs " of Muscle ? I think your comment was a bit harsh on Branch's Quads. I like Platz and certainly think that he owns ( STILL ) the greatest set of Quads EVER, however, you just can't dispute that Branch doesn't have a good set of Quads, too. Perhaps, I shouldn't have chose Branch ... maybe Paco Bautista or someone else, however, I will defend Branch first.

[The_Iron_Disciple]

And hopefully to redeem myself in your guy's Eyes ...  ... Paco Bautista !

[PANDAEMONIUM]

Narcissistic Deity, you have called for a truce.

Hulkster, have you accepted it yet?

[Iceman1981]

MR. OLYMPIA: EXPECTING THE UNEXPECTED
http://www.flexonline.com/news/245


"The man many consider the greatest bodybuilder who’s ever lived (Cutler himself has paid Coleman such a tribute) will no doubt squeeze every last ounce of potential from his superannuated self in his fight to regain his supremacy."

[Iceman1981]

BACK TO WORK
http://www.flexonline.com/training/97

"He’s still, in the estimation of many, the greatest bodybuilder who ever lived."

"FLEX returned there two weeks before last year’s Olympia to watch the then-reigning Mr. O work his back and biceps. His back — once the best ever

[tweeter]

Narcissistic Deity, you have called for a truce.

Hulkster, have you accepted it yet?

I think we just need a couple thousand more pages to settle it

[The Next BIG Thing!]

Colie! In this case it's hard to tell if you're being satirical!

Nah, I didn't say Platz was better than Coleman and/or Yates. I didn't even hint at a comparison.

I was just talking about legs and thighs in particular.

Nor was I talking in terms of the BB judging criteria that we've heard so much about. I'm just talking about what impresses little me!

As it happens, talk all you want about criteria, BB has always and will always be about personal opinion.

Criteria? It's like having criteria by which to judge apples and oranges.

Dat's wot I tink!



A

[suckmymuscle]

I am still waiting for you to explain how visual pics and videos have apparently no meaning or validity in this sport what so ever.

because if Peter McGough claimed Jay Cutler was black, and we posted pics showing otherwise, you would still believe Peter no matter what...

 


just like you have been doing with his comments about ronnie 99 compared to Ronnie 98:

ripped quads in 99, not so much in 98:

  Hulkster, pics that are taken with the same light, scale and contrast do have validity in evaluating physiques if you compare them according to the criteria. The problem is that you're comparing pics from different contests, with different lighting and angle, and focusing on irrelevant things like striations on the front quads - I've never seen striations win a contest.

SUCKMYMUSCLE

[Hulkster]

  Hulkster, pics that are taken with the same light, scale and contrast do have validity in evaluating physiques if you compare them according to the criteria. The problem is that you're comparing pics from different contests, with different lighting and angle, and focusing on irrelevant things like striations on the front quads - I've never seen striations win a contest.

SUCKMYMUSCLE

yes you have.

its just that they were only once peice of the pie - the others being shape, size, vascularity etc.

you can't single out any one trait in bodybuilding and say it doesn't really matter that much.

it doesn't work that way  - everything works together to create the effect.

come on sucky, you know better than that. Don't listen to someone like ND who does not understand how the sport is judged.

ND singles out stuff all the time and thinks it proves something.

it doesn't.

[xpac2]

yes you have.

its just that they were only once peice of the pie - the others being shape, size, vascularity etc.

you can't single out any one trait in bodybuilding and say it doesn't really matter that much.

it doesn't work that way  - everything works together to create the effect.

come on sucky, you know better than that. Don't listen to someone like ND who does not understand how the sport is judged.

ND singles out stuff all the time and thinks it proves something.

it doesn't.

Please answer my question on the previous page that I have for you. Thanks.

[NarcissisticDeity]

yes you have.

its just that they were only once peice of the pie - the others being shape, size, vascularity etc.

you can't single out any one trait in bodybuilding and say it doesn't really matter that much.

it doesn't work that way  - everything works together to create the effect.

come on sucky, you know better than that. Don't listen to someone like ND who does not understand how the sport is judged.

ND singles out stuff all the time and thinks it proves something.

it doesn't.

Look Hulkster one thing is clear especially concerning competitive bodybuilding , your oh-so great powers of deduction lead you to the conclusion Dorian Yates lost in 1993 lol enough said

I've always maintained Dorian meets the criteria better than Ronnie ALL of the criteria , muscle density , conditioning , balance & proportion , size , and posing and presentation YOU'VE yet to counter this and you can't because you don't even know what we're talking about and recall I said ALL ROUNDS ARE PHYSIQUE rounds , you're the one who constantly lists all the better parts Ronnie has lol yes very knowledgeable 
I own you kid

[NarcissisticDeity]

This my friend is the criteria thats exactly why he never placed below second place.

[Hulkster]

yes, you have maintained bullshit not validated by any of your comparisons..

eg. Ronnie has better size in the side tri, better shape, way more detail.

better density (dorian looks smooth), better everything, except for the calves.

one of the few things dorian actually has an advantage in..

tell us ND, what will your excuse be THIS time?

[NarcissisticDeity]

This my friend is the judging criteria from top to bottom

[NarcissisticDeity]

yes, you have maintained bullshit not validated by any of your comparisons..

eg. Ronnie has better size in the side tri, better shape, way more detail.

better density (dorian looks smooth), better everything, except for the calves.

one of the few things dorian actually has an advantage in..

tell us ND, what will your excuse be THIS time?

Not validated my comparisons to who you? I don't have to your the one who is asserting the insane , you constantly ignore the criteria that clearly favors Yates and harp type outright lies

Ronnie doesn't have better ' size ' thats moronic they both weigh 257 pounds Ronnie may have some better sized parts but as a whole ( keep that in mind ) Yates is something Ronnie is NOT 257 pounds bone dry & rock hard thats called density learn it kid

Any mandatory pose you pick Dorian has clear advantages in density ( especially Ronnie 99 ) conditioning , muscular bulk is a push however Dorian's is a better conditioned 257 pounds and Yates still has the clear advantages in balance & proportion and posing notice Coleman keeps his legs close together in the side triceps to TRY an minimize the effect of having two missing/underdeveloped calves

Yates is the criteria and thats why he never placed below second place in a contest in his LIFE you talk all this bullshit about how I don't know the criteria ( projection ) and my points have been validated by Pros and writers and yours have NOT sucker

Ronnie's best conditioned Olympia showing ( 1998 NOT 1999 ) and why? because his conditioning was bone dry & rock hard and to quote Coleman ' spot-on ' this proves YOU DON'T KNOW THE CRITERIA

you know nothing kid

[Hulkster]

it does not compare to this:

[NarcissisticDeity]

it does not compare to this:

No its superior to that 

[NarcissisticDeity]

it does not compare to this:

Look how mis-matched that front double biceps shot is and how unbalanced it is , Flex by the same token doesn't have outstanding balance but his front double biceps doesn't suffer for it like Ronnies

Ronnie forearms are dominated by his biceps/triceps throwing off his entire arm balance & proportion , his short torso doesn't ends abruptly at the round midsection  , quads dominating the pathetic calves throwing off his lower leg balance & proportion his entire front double biceps shot is lacking in terms of balance & proportion , you can't escape it and never will

This is a textbook front double biceps shot from head to toe.

[affy]

i swear...i randomly clicked three pages in this thread

and i saw the exact same pics all three pages.  get some new material...both sides...or just stfu

just sayin'

[pumpster]

Look Hulkster one thing is clear especially concerning competitive bodybuilding , your oh-so great powers of deduction lead you to the conclusion Dorian Yates lost in 1993 lol enough said

I've always maintained Dorian meets the criteria better than Ronnie ALL of the criteria , muscle density , conditioning , balance & proportion , size , and posing and presentation YOU'VE yet to counter this and you can't because you don't even know what we're talking about and recall I said ALL ROUNDS ARE PHYSIQUE rounds , you're the one who constantly lists all the better parts Ronnie has lol yes very knowledgeable 
I own you kid

Mr know-nothing recycles excuses about "judging criteria" while being completely befuddled & unable to explain Columbu's Olympias based on those criterias bwahahahaahahahahahah

OWNED, KID

Yates AKA "the Columbu of the 90s"

[NarcissisticDeity]

Mr know-nothing rambles on with the recycled excuse about "judging criteria" while being completely buffled and unable to explain Columbu's Olympias bwahahahaahahahahahah

OWNED

Get off my thread troll 

[pumpster]

Get off my thread troll 

The silence from this cretin on refusing to address my point is DEAFENING bwhaahahahahahahahahaha

Explain Columbu's wins based on your "judging criteria"

Yates, the Columbu of the 90s.

[NarcissisticDeity]

Mr know-nothing recycles excuses about "judging criteria" while being completely befuddled & unable to explain Columbu's Olympias based on those criterias bwahahahaahahahahahah

OWNED, KID

Yates AKA "the Columbu of the 90s"

Why do you always change your post after-the-fact ? and Yates was a born winner right out the cage.

Ronnie is the Franco of the 1990+ he languished in the back of the field for years before winning the big one  Dorian never placed below second in a pro contest find me another established pro who can boast that.