It’s very subjective. It all depends on how you like your men…..
Black and dumb or white and mute? That's tough.
Well Doz is winning now. Getting high, staying in shape, prioritizing physical health, banging a hot tranny. Versus Ronnie, being carted around in a wheel chair and getting his ass wiped by his mudshark.
But as bodybuilders its not really even close. At their competitive BEST Dorian in 93 and Ronnie in 03, Ronnie had everything Dorian had but more. Bigger, just as hard, just as dense, just as ripped. The only thing Dorian had Ronnie on was calves and forearms.
Obsidian provides a pretty good analysis but I have to disagree with a few of his choices. As good as Dorians side chest and front lat spread were, Ronnie in 03 is beats him in those poses. So instead of 4 apiece its more like 6-2.
Then there's the total victories. Ronnie has close to 30 while Dorian has like 10. Then total Olympia victories. Ronnie has 8 with 1 being slightly controversial. Dorian has 6 with at least 2 being very controversial.
Also, Dorian never really truly put the controversy to rest. You can argue that he never really shut up Shawn Ray or Nasser. While I do think Dorian deserved his wins in 95 and 96 , they were extremely close. 94was bad and 97 was atrocious. Ronnie had 1 close call with Jay in 01 but beat him roundly every year thereafter.
Even the year Jay won in 06 was kind of bullshit. Dorian got every close call and then some and still couldn't come close to 8 sandows. Ronnie tbh looked like anytime it was close "they" were anxious to see him get beat. Letting Gunther beat him at the Show of Strength? And Giving it to Jay in 06? Ronnie never received the kind of favors Dorian did. Ronnie earned each of his Olympias and damn near 3 times as many pro victories as Dorian.
Bigger, stronger, just as ripped, better body parts, arms, chest, thighs with a back that neutralized Dorians bread and butter muscle group. Both their abs were weird but Doz lost complete control of his abs, oblique and waist, while Ronnie always kept a V taper even when his waist grew out of control.
Im a fan of Dorian too, but Ronnie was everything Dorian was just bigger and better.