It doesn't matter. To knock off the MR. Olympia you have to set a new standard, which Jay did not. If anything, he regressed the sport with his saggy abs, 45" waist, and refrigerator structure. Martinez looked miles better (although still no where near Ronnie's 98 form).
first of all,
To win a contest, you must have the best physique.
"setting a new standard" is not part of the judging criteria
if coleman looks like shit (like he did last week) and Jay looks better, then coleman should lose
second,
Jay did set a new standard as the first 270lb+ mr olympia without a 40" waist!
third,
the only person who has effectively regressed this sport is ronnie coleman himself
for taking his physique from 250lbs lean shredded mass to 300lbs of shit.