Only if you concede that a title shot automatically confers top 5 status.
Hell no, that would be like considering Zulu-zinho a top five HW just for getting the chance to lose to Fedor. (granted the belt wasn't on the line, Fedor was still the champ) In my book, he gets top five by beating a top five. I know he wants a shot at Randy and Dana may oblige just for the freakshow value if anything, not because he deserves it.