I don't know what is worse - the hysteria or the hypocrisy?
I don't post much but I've lurked around these boards (admittedly only the gossip and training ones) for a good few years now.
I trained for years naturally, I've used gear, been through life, had many experiences good and bad (related to bodybuilding lifestyle).
I have no idea who GH15 is, don't particularly care either.
But I have actually bothered to read his posts, reasonably carefully. I don't slavishly follow anybody's advice, by the way, my knowledge and bb intelligence has been amassed from observing others, but largely doing my own thing - making my own mistakes, trying to find out what works etc.
Just recently I went through the majority of GH15's posts and in those areas, where I have some knowledge I have found that his ideas pretty much mirror my own. So for me alot of what he says I agree with by dint of personal observation and experimentation. I can't comment on everything he says because i don't have the requisite experience but what I can say is that I am far more likely to ask his advice, based on what he has thus far provided, than bend the ear of most of the so called other gurus.
If he is some basement 100 pound gimmick (which I doubt) then to me, he is probably an idiot savant because he clearly knows alot, and alot of factual stuff. But from the way I interpret his stuff I will be very suprised to find out (if we ever do) that he wasn't a very experienced bodybuilder. Either way he clearly has a passion for this game and despite some of his ramblings, the content that I am interested in has been an education for me and like I say a breath of fresh air compared to the much of the BS that permeates the cult.
Anyways - as far as I was aware we live in a democracy - ideas and information should and must be allowed to flow freely. GH15 maybe controversial for many reasons but in amongst all the hysteria, mystery and hypocrisy GH15's primary message, I think, is pretty clear and consistent. If you are a reasonably normal, sane and intelligent human being then his advice and information isn't going to present too many problems for you. If you are a moron then if you take any advice from anybody you are still going to be a moron.
Just my two cents.